On the Quantitative Impact of the Schechter-Valle Theorem

Abstract

We evaluate the Schechter-Valle (Black Box) theorem quantitatively by considering the most general Lorentz invariant Lagrangian consisting of point-like operators for neutrinoless double beta decay. It is well known that the Black Box operators induce Majorana neutrino masses at four-loop level. This warrants the statement that an observation of neutrinoless double beta decay guarantees the Majorana nature of neutrinos. We calculate these radiatively generated masses and find that they are many orders of magnitude smaller than the observed neutrino masses and splittings. Thus, some lepton number violating New Physics (which may at tree-level not be related to neutrino masses) may induce Black Box operators which can explain an observed rate of neutrinoless double beta decay. Although these operators guarantee finite Majorana neutrino masses, the smallness of the Black Box contributions implies that other neutrino mass terms (Dirac or Majorana) must exist. If neutrino masses have a significant Majorana contribution then this will become the dominant part of the Black Box operator. However, neutrinos might also be predominantly Dirac particles, while other lepton number violating New Physics dominates neutrinoless double beta decay. Translating an observed rate of neutrinoless double beta decay into neutrino masses would then be completely misleading. Although the principal statement of the Schechter-Valle theorem remains valid, we conclude that the Black Box diagram itself generates radiatively only mass terms which are many orders of magnitude too small to explain neutrino masses. Therefore, other operators must give the leading contributions to neutrino masses, which could be of Dirac or Majorana nature.

18 pages, 4 figures; v2: minor corrections, reference added, matches journal version; v3: typo corrected, physics result and conclusions unchanged

References in corpus (5)

• Results from a search for the $0\nu \beta \beta$-decay of ${}^{130}Te$
• Extended Black Box Theorem for Lepton Number and Flavor Violating processes
• Few active mechanisms of the neutrinoless double beta-decay and effective mass of Majorana neutrinos
• Constraining New Physics with a Positive or Negative Signal of Neutrino-less Double Beta Decay
• Measurement of the double beta decay half-life of Nd-150 and search for neutrinoless decay modes with the NEMO-3 detector

Cited by in corpus (83)

• Massive Gravity
• Colloquium: Majorana Fermions in nuclear, particle and solid-state physics
• Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay: Status and Prospects
• Neutrinoless double beta decay: 2015 review
• A White Paper on keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
• Neutrino Mass and Mixing: from Theory to Experiment
• From the trees to the forest: a review of radiative neutrino mass models
• Flavor structures of charged fermions and massive neutrinos
• Toward the discovery of matter creation with neutrinoless double-beta decay
• Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay: a Probe of Physics Beyond the Standard Model
• Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay and Heavy Sterile Neutrinos
• Lepton Flavor and Number Conservation, and Physics Beyond the Standard Model
• The Present and Future Status of Heavy Neutral Leptons
• Heavy Neutrinos and Lepton Flavour Violation in Left-Right Symmetric Models at the LHC
• Lepton number and flavour violation in TeV-scale left-right symmetric theories with large left-right mixing
• Neutrino Non-Standard Interactions: A Status Report
• New Production Mechanism for keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter by Decays of Frozen-In Scalars
• Discovery probability of next-generation neutrinoless double-$\beta$ decay experiments
• Vector boson fusion at multi-TeV muon colliders
• Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
• keV Neutrino Model Building
• Dirac Neutrinos and Dark Matter Stability from Lepton Quarticity
• Dirac neutrinos from flavor symmetry
• New expectations and uncertainties on neutrinoless double beta decay
• The coupling to matter in Massive, Bi- and Multi-Gravity
• Status and prospects of searches for neutrinoless double beta decay
• Generalized $\mu -\tau$ reflection symmetry and leptonic CP violation
• Systematic decomposition of the neutrinoless double beta decay operator
• Neutrino masses and mixing: a flavour symmetry roadmap
• Effective Lagrangian approach to neutrinoless double beta decay and neutrino masses
• Searches for Long-Lived Particles at the Future FCC-ee
• Running of Radiative Neutrino Masses: The Scotogenic Model - REVISITED
• Beyond-mean-field approaches for nuclear neutrinoless double beta decay in the standard mechanism
• The Power of Neutrino Mass Sum Rules for Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay Experiments
• Constraining neutrinoless double beta decay
• Short-range mechanisms of neutrinoless double beta decay at the LHC
• A new neutrino mass sum rule from inverse seesaw
• CP Violation from Flavor Symmetry in a Lepton Quarticity Dark Matter Model
• Flavour-symmetric type-II Dirac neutrino seesaw mechanism
• Can one ever prove that neutrinos are Dirac particles?
• Majorana CP-violating phases in neutrino-antineutrino oscillations and other lepton-number-violating processes
• Classifying CP transformations according to their texture zeros: theory and implications
• Warm Dark Matter from keVins
• Double beta decay and neutrino mass models
• Extracting Majorana Properties in the Throat of Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
• Exploding operators for Majorana neutrino masses and beyond
• The symmetry approach to quark and lepton masses and mixing
• A realistic model of neutrino masses with a large neutrinoless double beta decay rate
• Observable Lepton Number Violation with Predominantly Dirac Nature of Active Neutrinos
• CUORE Sensitivity to $0\nu \beta \beta$ Decay
• Confirmation of $g_{\mathrm{A}}$ quenching using the revised spectrum-shape method for the analysis of the ${}^{113}$Cd $\beta$-decay as measured with the COBRA demonstrator
• On the Viability of Minimal Neutrinophilic Two-Higgs-Doublet Models
• Distinguishing Dirac and Majorana Heavy Neutrinos at Lepton Colliders
• Influence of a keV sterile neutrino on neutrino-less double beta decay -- how things changed in the recent years
• Probing nonstandard lepton number violating interactions in neutrino oscillations
• Lepton Number Violation: Seesaw Models and Their Collider Tests
• Probing flavor models with Ge-76-based experiments on neutrinoless double-beta decay
• Long-range contributions to double beta decay revisited
• Majorana Neutrino Masses from Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decays and Lepton-Number-Violating Meson Decays
• Constraints on lepton number violating short-range interactions from $|\Delta L|=2$ processes
• Determining Majorana Nature of Neutrino from Nucleon Decays and n-nbar oscillations
• Another look at the impact of an eV-mass sterile neutrino on the effective neutrino mass of neutrinoless double-beta decays
• Neutrinoless double beta decay and QCD running at low energy scales
• Twelve-crystal prototype of Li${}_2$MoO${}_4$ scintillating bolometers for CUPID and CROSS experiments
• Neutrino 2020: Theory Outlook
• Roles of sterile neutrinos in particle physics and cosmology
• Constraints on the Active and Sterile Neutrino Masses from Beta-Ray Spectra: Past, Present and Future
• Decomposition of $d=9$ short-range $0\nu \beta \beta$ decay operators at one-loop level
• Uncovering a chirally suppressed mechanism of $0\nu \beta \beta$ decay with LHC searches
• On the lepton CP violation in a $\nu$2HDM with flavor
• Translation invariant time-dependent solutions to massive gravity
• Flavoured Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
• Neutrinoless double $\beta$ decay with small neutrino masses
• Space-Time Discriminant to Separate Double-Beta Decay from ${}^8$B Solar Neutrinos in Liquid Scintillator
• Dark matter as the source of neutrino mass: theory overview and experimental prospects
• Probability Densities of the effective neutrino masses $m_{\beta }$ and $m_{\beta \beta }$
• Consequences of Neutrinoless Double Decays Dominated by Short Range Interactions
• Correspondence between the contracted BTZ solution of cosmological topological massive gravity and two-dimensional Galilean conformal algebra
• Status and Perspectives of Neutrino Physics
• The Nature of the Neutrino (Dirac/Majorana) and Double Beta Decay with or without Neutrinos
• Status and implications of neutrino masses: a brief panorama
• $\rho$ exchange contribution to neutrinoless double beta decay
• Theory and phenomenology of Dirac neutrinos