Comment on "The Jones-Hore theory of radical-ion-pair reactions is not self-consistent" (arXiv:1010.3888v3)
arXiv:1103.1515 · doi:10.1016/j.cplett.2011.04.022
Abstract
A short comment on "The Jones-Hore theory of radical-ion-pair reactions is not self-consistent" (arXiv:1010.3888v3) is presented. In the comment, it is pointed out that the paper includes a misconception about the Jones-Hore approach in Chem. Phys. Lett. 488 (2010) 90-93. The re-formulation is presented and it is demonstrated that the Jones-Hore theory is consistent at least on the point claimed by I. K. Kominis in the paper.
References in corpus (5)
- Postselected versus nonpostselected quantum teleportation using parametric down-conversion
- Spin-selective reactions of radical pairs act as quantum measurements
- Reaction operators for spin-selective chemical reactions of radical pairs
- Second Comment on "Spin-selective reactions of radical pairs act as quantum measurements" (Chemical Physics Letters 488 (2010) 90-93)
- The Jones-Hore theory of radical-ion-pair reactions is not self-consistent
Cited by in corpus (11)
- Quantum coherence and sensitivity of avian magnetoreception
- Spin-selective electron transfer reactions of radical pairs: beyond the Haberkorn master equation
- The radical-pair mechanism as a paradigm for the emerging science of quantum biology
- Coherent chemical kinetics as quantum walks I: Reaction operators for radical pairs
- Hamiltonian Simulation of Quantum Beats in Radical Pairs Undergoing Thermal Relaxation on Near-term Quantum Computers
- Should recombinations of radical pairs be considered as accompanied by measurements?
- Extraction of Isotropic Electron-Nuclear Hyperfine Coupling Constants of Paramagnetic Point Defects from Near-Zero Field Magnetoresistance Spectra via Least Squares Fitting to Models Developed from the Stochastic Quantum Liouville Equation
- Reactant-Product Quantum Coherence in Electron Transfer Reactions
- Multiple re-encounter approach to radical pair reactions and the role of nonlinear master equations
- Photon statistics as an experimental test discriminating between theories of spin-selective radical-ion-pair reactions
- Quantum Information Processing in the Radical-Pair Mechanism: Haberkorn theory violates the Ozawa entropy bound