Thermodynamical inequivalence of quantum stress-energy and spin tensors

Abstract

It is shown that different couples of stress-energy and spin tensors of quantum relativistic fields, which would be otherwise equivalent, are in fact inequivalent if the second law of thermodynamics is taken into account. The proof of the inequivalence is based on the analysis of a macroscopic system at full thermodynamical equilibrium with a macroscopic total angular momentum and a specific instance is given for the free Dirac field, for which we show that the canonical and Belinfante stress-energy tensors are not equivalent. For this particular case, we show that the difference between the predicted angular momentum densities for a rotating system at full thermodynamical equilibrium is a quantum effect, persisting in the non-relativistic limit, corresponding to a polarization of particles of the order of \hbar ω/KT (ωbeing the angular velocity) and could in principle be measured experimentally. This result implies that specific stress-energy and spin tensors are physically meaningful even in the absence of gravitational coupling and raises the issue of finding the thermodynamically right (or the right class of) tensors. We argue that the maximization of the thermodynamic potential theoretically allows to discriminate between two different couples, yet for the present we are unable to provide a theoretical method to single out the "best" couple of tensors in a given quantum field theory. The existence of a non-vanishing spin tensor would have major consequences in hydrodynamics, gravity and cosmology.

25 pages, 3 figures. Final version accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. D

References in corpus (2)

• Fermionic vacuum polarization by a cylindrical boundary in the cosmic string spacetime
• The microcanonical ensemble of the ideal relativistic quantum gas with angular momentum conservation

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Interacting fermions in rotation: chiral symmetry restoration, moment of inertia and thermodynamics
• Spin Hydrodynamics and Symmetric Energy-Momentum Tensors -- A current induced by the spin vorticity --
• Local thermodynamical equilibrium and the beta frame for a quantum relativistic fluid
• Spin tensor and pseudo-gauges: from nuclear collisions to gravitational physics
• Spin and polarization: a new direction in relativistic heavy ion physics
• Relativistic second-order spin hydrodynamics: an entropy-current analysis
• Exact equilibrium distributions in statistical quantum field theory with rotation and acceleration: scalar field
• Pseudogauge dependence of the spin polarization and of the axial vortical effect
• Pseudo-gauges and relativistic spin hydrodynamics for interacting Dirac and Proca fields
• Stability studies of first order spin-hydrodynamic frameworks
• The causality and stability of relativistic spin-hydrodynamics
• Extensivity, entropy current, area law and Unruh effect
• Thermodynamic equilibrium of massless fermions with vorticity, chirality and electromagnetic field
• Hybrid approach to perfect and dissipative spin hydrodynamics
• Pseudogauge freedom and the SO(3) algebra of spin operators
• Emergent Canonical Spin Tensor in the Chiral-Symmetric Hot QCD
• Conserved and non-conserved Noether currents from the quantum effective action
• Pseudogauge ambiguity in the distributions of energy density, pressure, and shear force inside the nucleon
• Causal fermion states in magnetic field in a relativistic rotating frame and electromagnetic radiation by a rapidly rotating charge
• Energy-momentum tensor form factors and spin density distribution in the nucleon calculated in a quantized Skyrme model with vector mesons
• Entropy current in relativistic quantum statistical mechanics
• On the local thermodynamic relations in relativistic spin hydrodynamics
• A New Improved Energy-Momentum Tensor and Its Possible Role in Gravity