Complex Langevin: Etiology and Diagnostics of its Main Problem

Abstract

The complex Langevin method is a leading candidate for solving the so-called sign problem occurring in various physical situations. Its most vexing problem is that in some cases it produces `convergence to the wrong limit'. In the first part of the paper we go through the formal justification of the method, identify points at which it may fail and identify a necessary and sufficient criterion for correctness. This criterion would, however, require checking infinitely many identities, and therefore is somewhat academic. We propose instead a truncation to the check of a few identities; this still gives a necessary criterion, but a priori it is not clear whether it remains sufficient. In the second part we carry out a detailed study of two toy models: first we identify the reasons why in some cases the method fails, second we test the efficiency of the truncated criterion and find that it works perfectly at least in the toy models studied.

39 pages, 15 figures; typos corrected and reference added

References in corpus (12)

• The Complex Langevin method: When can it be trusted?
• Can stochastic quantization evade the sign problem? -- the relativistic Bose gas at finite chemical potential
• Lattice simulations of real-time quantum fields
• Adaptive stepsize and instabilities in complex Langevin dynamics
• Stochastic quantization at finite chemical potential
• Simulating nonequilibrium quantum fields with stochastic quantization techniques
• Real-time gauge theory simulations from stochastic quantization with optimized updating
• Complex Langevin dynamics at finite chemical potential: mean field analysis in the relativistic Bose gas
• On the convergence of complex Langevin dynamics: the three-dimensional XY model at finite chemical potential
• Complex Langevin Equations and Schwinger-Dyson Equations
• Degenerate distributions in complex Langevin dynamics: one-dimensional QCD at finite chemical potential
• Effective Potential for Complex Langevin Equations

Cited by in corpus (145)

• Simulating full QCD at nonzero density using the complex Langevin equation
• Review on novel methods for lattice gauge theories
• Critical point in the phase diagram of primordial quark-gluon matter from black hole physics
• Gauge cooling in complex Langevin for QCD with heavy quarks
• Hybrid Monte Carlo on Lefschetz Thimbles -- A study of the residual sign problem
• The QCD equation of state from the lattice
• Finite-density lattice QCD and sign problem: current status and open problems
• Controlling complex Langevin dynamics at finite density
• The argument for justification of the complex Langevin method and the condition for correct convergence
• Introductory lectures on lattice QCD at nonzero baryon number
• New insights into the problem with a singular drift term in the complex Langevin method
• Complex Langevin Dynamics for chiral Random Matrix Theory
• Critical line of 2+1 flavor QCD: Toward the continuum limit
• Lefschetz-thimble analysis of the sign problem in one-site fermion model
• Complex Langevin dynamics in the SU(3) spin model at nonzero chemical potential revisited
• Vacuum structure of bifundamental gauge theories at finite topological angles
• Some remarks on Lefschetz thimbles and complex Langevin dynamics
• Complex Langevin dynamics and zeroes of the fermion determinant
• Complex Langevin and other approaches to the sign problem in quantum many-body physics
• Complex Langevin analysis of the space-time structure in the Lorentzian type IIB matrix model
• Lefschetz thimble structure in one-dimensional lattice Thirring model at finite density
• Stability of complex Langevin dynamics in effective models
• Complex Langevin dynamics for dynamical QCD at nonzero chemical potential: a comparison with multi-parameter reweighting
• Parallel tempering algorithm for integration over Lefschetz thimbles
• Lefschetz thimbles and stochastic quantisation: Complex actions in the complex plane
• Complex Langevin and boundary terms
• Monte Carlo simulation of the SU(3) spin model with chemical potential in a flux representation
• Localised distributions and criteria for correctness in complex Langevin dynamics
• Full simulation of chiral Random Matrix Theory at non-zero chemical potential by Complex Langevin
• Phase transitions and gluodynamics in 2-colour matter at high density
• Energy loss, equilibration, and thermodynamics of a baryon rich strongly coupled quark-gluon plasma
• Status of Complex Langevin
• Justification of the complex Langevin method with the gauge cooling procedure
• The QCD phase diagram in the limit of heavy quarks using complex Langevin dynamics
• Applying the tempered Lefschetz thimble method to the Hubbard model away from half-filling
• Does the complex Langevin method give unbiased results?
• Controlling Complex Langevin simulations of lattice models by boundary term analysis
• New approach to lattice QCD at finite density; results for the critical end point on coarse lattices
• Complex saddle points and the sign problem in complex Langevin simulation
• Calculating the EoS of the dense quark-gluon plasma using the Complex Langevin equation
• Applying Complex Langevin Simulations to Lattice QCD at Finite Density
• Thermal photon and dilepton production and electric charge transport in a baryon rich strongly coupled QGP from holography
• Surmounting the sign problem in non-relativistic calculations: a case study with mass-imbalanced fermions
• Heavy dense QCD and nuclear matter from an effective lattice theory
• Finite-temperature equation of state of polarized fermions at unitarity
• Complex Langevin simulations and the QCD phase diagram: Recent developments
• Third-order perturbative lattice and complex Langevin analyses of the finite-temperature equation of state of non-relativistic fermions in one dimension
• Complex Langevin analysis of the spontaneous symmetry breaking in dimensionally reduced super Yang-Mills models
• Thermodynamics of strong-interaction matter from Lattice QCD
• Dynamical stabilisation of complex Langevin simulations of QCD
• Thirring model at finite density in 0+1 dimensions with stochastic quantization: Crosscheck with an exact solution
• Gauge cooling for the singular-drift problem in the complex Langevin method --a test in Random Matrix Theory for finite density QCD
• An improvement in complex Langevin dynamics from a view point of Lefschetz thimbles
• Combining the complex Langevin method and the generalized Lefschetz-thimble method
• Worldvolume approach to the tempered Lefschetz thimble method
• Progress in the numerical studies of the type IIB matrix model
• Diffusion Models as Stochastic Quantization in Lattice Field Theory
• Complex Langevin calculations in finite density QCD at large $\mu /T$ with the deformation technique
• The complex Langevin analysis of spontaneous symmetry breaking induced by complex fermion determinant
• A simple approach towards the sign problem using path optimisation
• A complex path around the sign problem
• Tensor renormalization group study of the 3d $O(2)$ model
• Thermal quantum time-correlation functions from classical-like dynamics
• Thirring model at finite density in 2+1 dimensions with stochastic quantization
• Backpropagating Hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm for fast Lefschetz thimble calculations
• Gradient flows without blow-up for Lefschetz thimbles
• New developments for dual methods in lattice field theory at non-zero density
• Reweighting complex Langevin trajectories
• Spin Polarized Non-Relativistic Fermions in 1+1 Dimensions
• Testing the criterion for correct convergence in the complex Langevin method
• Thermodynamics of spin-orbit coupled bosons in two dimensions from complex Langevin
• Complex Langevin calculations in QCD at finite density
• Polarized fermions in one dimension: density and polarization from complex Langevin calculations, perturbation theory, and the virial expansion
• Application of Bootstrap to $\theta$-term
• Complex Langevin analysis of the spontaneous breaking of 10D rotational symmetry in the Euclidean IKKT matrix model
• Towards learning optimized kernels for complex Langevin
• Complex Langevin method applied to the 2D $SU(2)$ Yang-Mills theory
• On the gauge invariant path-integral measure for the overlap Weyl fermions in $\underline{16}$ of SO(10)
• Pairing patterns in one-dimensional spin- and mass-imbalanced Fermi gases
• Modifying partition functions: a way to solve the sign problem
• Why is the mission impossible? -- Decoupling the mirror Ginsparg-Wilson fermions in the lattice models for two-dimensional abelian chiral gauge theories
• Complex Langevin: Boundary terms at poles
• Phase diagram of the quantum O(2)-model in 2+1 dimensions
• Complex Langevin Simulations of Zero-dimensional Supersymmetric Quantum Field Theories
• Complex Langevin Dynamics in Large $N$ Unitary Matrix Models
• Monte Carlo studies of the spontaneous rotational symmetry breaking in dimensionally reduced super Yang-Mills models
• A practical solution to the sign problem in a matrix model for dynamical compactification
• Complex Langevin simulations of a finite density matrix model for QCD
• Restricted phase-space approximation in real-time stochastic quantization
• On the structure of the emergent 3d expanding space in the Lorentzian type IIB matrix model
• Gibbs sampling of complex valued distributions
• Temporal breakdown and Borel resummation in the complex Langevin method
• Improved convergence of Complex Langevin simulations
• Distance between configurations in Markov chain Monte Carlo simulations
• Complex Langevin studies of the emergent space-time in the type IIB matrix model
• Complex Langevin Simulations of QCD at Finite Density -- Progress Report
• Schwinger-Dyson equations and line integrals
• Complex Langevin for Lattice QCD at $T=0$ and $\mu \ge 0$
• A complex Langevin approach to ultracold fermions
• Complex Langevin study for polarons in an attractively interacting one-dimensional two-component Fermi gas
• Beyond complex Langevin equations II: a positive representation of Feynman path integrals directly in the Minkowski time
• Test for a universal behavior of Dirac eigenvalues in the complex Langevin method
• Comparison of algorithms for solving the sign problem in the O(3) model in 1+1 dimensions at finite chemical potential
• Selected inversion as key to a stable Langevin evolution across the QCD phase boundary
• Beyond Complex Langevin Equations: positive representation of a class of complex measures
• QCD at nonzero chemical potential: recent progress on the lattice
• Lefschetz thimble-inspired weight regularizations for complex Langevin simulations
• Getting even with CLE
• Testing a generalized cooling procedure in the complex Langevin simulation of chiral Random Matrix Theory
• Color superconductivity on the lattice -- analytic predictions from QCD in a small box
• Fermion Bag Approach for Massive Thirring Model at Finite Density
• Complex Langevin simulation of QCD at finite density and low temperature using the deformation technique
• Positive Representations of a Class of Complex Measures
• Testing dynamic stabilisation in complex Langevin simulations
• Complex Langevin Dynamics and Supersymmetric Quantum Mechanics
• Complex Langevin analysis of 2D U(1) gauge theory on a torus with a $\theta$ term
• Unification of the complex Langevin method and the Lefschetz-thimble method
• Beyond complex Langevin equations I: two simple examples
• Towards sampling complex actions
• Positive representations of complex distributions on groups
• Explicit positive representation for weights on $R^d$
• Lefschetz Thimbles and Quantum Phases in Zero-Dimensional Bosonic Models
• Advances in non-relativistic matter via complex Langevin approaches
• Complex Langevin Method on Rotating Matrix Quantum Mechanics at Thermal Equilibrium
• Satisfying positivity requirement in the Beyond Complex Langevin approach
• The Role of Integration Cycles in Complex Langevin Simulations
• Necessary and sufficient conditions for correctness of complex Langevin
• Holographic de Sitter Spacetime and Quantum Corrections to The Cosmological Constant
• Performance of Complex Langevin Simulation in 0+1 dimensional massive Thirring model at finite density
• Real-time Quantum evolution in the Classical approximation and beyond
• Beyond Complex Langevin Equations: a Progress Report
• Classical Statistical simulation of Quantum Field Theory
• A lattice pairing-field approach to ultracold Fermi gases
• Is it worth the effort to find Lefschetz thimbles? Integration contours with numerically optimal signal-to-noise ratios in simple fermionic toy models
• Exploring the QCD phase diagram at finite density by the complex Langevin method on a $16^3\times 32$ lattice
• On the validity of the complex Langevin method near the deconfining phase transition in QCD at finite density
• Lattice String Field Theory: The linear dilaton in one dimension
• Combining complex Langevin dynamics with score-based and energy-based diffusion models
• Complex Langevin for Lattice QCD
• Dynamical Compactification of Extra Dimensions in the Euclidean IKKT Matrix Model via Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
• Dynamical compactification of extra dimensions in the Euclidean type IIB matrix model: A numerical study using the complex Langevin method
• Can the complex Langevin method see the deconfinement phase transition in QCD at finite density?
• Markovian versus non-Markovian stochastic quantization of a complex-action model
• Spontaneous symmetry breaking induced by complex fermion determinant --- yet another success of the complex Langevin method
• Correctness criteria for complex Langevin