A Critical Examination of the X-Wind Model for Chondrule and Calcium-rich, Aluminum-rich Inclusion Formation and Radionuclide Production

Abstract

Meteoritic data, especially regarding chondrules and calcium-rich, aluminum-rich inclusions (CAIs), and isotopic evidence for short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) in the solar nebula, potentially can constrain how planetary systems form. Intepretation of these data demands an astrophysical model, and the "X-wind" model of Shu et al. (1996) and collaborators has been advanced to explain the origin of chondrules, CAIs and SLRs. It posits that chondrules and CAIs were thermally processed < 0.1 AU from the protostar, then flung by a magnetocentrifugal outflow to the 2-3 AU region to be incorporated into chondrites. Here we critically examine key assumptions and predictions of the X-wind model. We find a number of internal inconsistencies: theory and observation show no solid material exists at 0.1 AU; particles at 0.1 AU cannot escape being accreted into the star; particles at 0.1 AU will collide at speeds high enough to destroy them; thermal sputtering will prevent growth of particles; and launching of particles in magnetocentrifugal outflows is not modeled, and may not be possible. We also identify a number of incorrect predictions of the X-wind model: the oxygen fugacity where CAIs form is orders of magnitude too oxidizing; chondrule cooling rates are orders of magnitude lower than those experienced by barred olivine chondrules; chondrule-matrix complementarity is not predicted; and the SLRs are not produced in their observed proportions. We conclude that the X-wind model is not relevant to chondrule and CAI formation and SLR production. We discuss more plausible models for chondrule and CAI formation and SLR production.

Accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal

References in corpus (13)

• Towards planetesimals: dense chondrule clumps in the protoplanetary nebula
• X-ray flares in Orion young stars. I. Flare characteristics
• The Inner Rim Structures of Protoplanetary Discs
• Interaction of Supernova Ejecta with Nearby Protoplanetary Disks
• HH 212: SMA Observations of a Remarkable Protostellar Jet
• Gravitational Instabilities, Chondrule Formation, and the FU Orionis Phenomenon
• Thermal Histories of Chondrules in Solar Nebula Shocks
• Radioactive Probes of the Supernova-Contaminated Solar Nebula: Evidence that the Sun was Born in a Cluster
• On the Structure of the Turbulent Interstellar Clouds
• Injection of Short-Lived Radionuclides into the Early Solar System from a Faint Supernova with Mixing-Fallback
• Triggering Collapse of the Presolar Dense Cloud Core and Injecting Short-Lived Radioisotopes with a Shock Wave. I. Varied Shock Speeds
• Supernova Propagation And Cloud Enrichment: A new model for the origin of ${}^{60}$Fe in the early solar system
• Who Pulled the Trigger: a Supernova or an AGB Star?

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Radioactive nuclei from cosmochronology to habitability
• 26Al in the Early Solar System: Not so Unusual After All
• Solar System Physics for Exoplanet Research
• Mixing of Clumpy Supernova Ejecta into Molecular Clouds
• Dust Transport and Processing in Centrifugally Driven Protoplanetary Disk Winds
• Cosmochemical Consequences of Particle Trajectories During FU Orionis Outbursts by the Early Sun
• The quasi-universality of chondrule size as a constraint for chondrule formation models
• Formation and evolution of a protoplanetary disk: combining observations, simulations and cosmochemical constraints
• Paleomagnetic evidence for a disk substructure in the early solar system
• Distributions of Short-Lived Radioactive Nuclei Produced by Young Embedded Stellar Clusters
• Early planet formation in embedded protostellar disks: Setting the stage for the first generation of planetesimals
• Transport of solids in protoplanetary disks: Comparing meteorites and astrophysical models
• On vertical variations of gas flow in protoplanetary disks and their impact on the transport of solids
• On beryllium-10 production in gaseous protoplanetary disks and implications on the astrophysical setting of refractory inclusions
• The effect of multiple particle sizes on cooling rates of chondrules produced in large-scale shocks in the solar nebula
• Inner dusty regions of protoplanetary discs -- II. Dust dynamics driven by radiation pressure and disc winds
• Refractory Metal Nuggets -- Formation of the First Condensates in the Solar Nebula
• Magnetic Fields Recorded by Chondrules Formed in Nebular Shocks
• Nebular history of an ultrarefractory phase bearing CAI from a reduced type CV chondrite
• Theoretical Distributions of Short-Lived Radionuclides for Star Formation in Molecular Clouds
• Physicochemical Controls on the Compositions of the Earth and Planets
• Asteroids and Comets
• Formation of stars and planets: the role of magnetic fields
• Stellar outbursts and chondrite composition
• Hypothesis about Enrichment of Solar System
• Cosmic-Ray Bath in a Past Supernova Gives Birth to Earth-Like Planets
• Possible Solution to the Triple Alpha Fine-Tuning Problem: Spallation Reactions during Planet Formation
• Self-consistent Conditions for ${}^{26}$Al Injection into Protosolar Disk from a Nearby Supernova
• Radioactive Planet Formation