Opinion fluctuations and disagreement in social networks

Abstract

We study a tractable opinion dynamics model that generates long-run disagreements and persistent opinion fluctuations. Our model involves an inhomogeneous stochastic gossip process of continuous opinion dynamics in a society consisting of two types of agents: regular agents, who update their beliefs according to information that they receive from their social neighbors; and stubborn agents, who never update their opinions. When the society contains stubborn agents with different opinions, the belief dynamics never lead to a consensus (among the regular agents). Instead, beliefs in the society fail to converge almost surely, the belief profile keeps on fluctuating in an ergodic fashion, and it converges in law to a non-degenerate random vector. The structure of the network and the location of the stubborn agents within it shape the opinion dynamics. The expected belief vector evolves according to an ordinary differential equation coinciding with the Kolmogorov backward equation of a continuous-time Markov chain with absorbing states corresponding to the stubborn agents and converges to a harmonic vector, with every regular agent's value being the weighted average of its neighbors' values, and boundary conditions corresponding to the stubborn agents'. Expected cross-products of the agents' beliefs allow for a similar characterization in terms of coupled Markov chains on the network. We prove that, in large-scale societies which are highly fluid, meaning that the product of the mixing time of the Markov chain on the graph describing the social network and the relative size of the linkages to stubborn agents vanishes as the population size grows large, a condition of \emph{homogeneous influence} emerges, whereby the stationary beliefs' marginal distributions of most of the regular agents have approximately equal first and second moments.

33 pages, accepted for publication in Mathematics of Operation Research

References in corpus (5)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Does a Single Zealot Affect an Infinite Group of Voters ?
• A stabilization theorem for dynamics of continuous opinions
• Voting and Catalytic Processes with Inhomogeneities
• Scaling limits for continuous opinion dynamics systems

Cited by in corpus (41)

• A Tutorial on Modeling and Analysis of Dynamic Social Networks. Part II
• Measuring Political Polarization: Twitter shows the two sides of Venezuela
• Simplicial SIS model in scale-free uniform hypergraph
• Filtering Random Graph Processes Over Random Time-Varying Graphs
• Nonlinear $q$-voter model with inflexible zealots
• Active Sensing of Social Networks
• A two-layer model for coevolving opinion dynamics and collective decision-making in complex social systems
• A Model for the Influence of Media on the Ideology of Content in Online Social Networks
• Scaling limits for continuous opinion dynamics systems
• Characterization of the Nonequilibrium Steady State of a Heterogeneous Nonlinear $q$-Voter Model with Zealotry
• Effective epidemic containment strategy in hypergraphs
• A Heterogeneous Out-of-Equilibrium Nonlinear $q$-Voter Model with Zealotry
• From local averaging to emergent global behaviors: the fundamental role of network interconnections
• Predicting Opinion Dynamics via Sociologically-Informed Neural Networks
• Finite-time Convergent Gossiping
• The Impact Of Noise And Topology On Opinion Dynamics In Social Networks
• Analysing kinetic transition networks for rare events
• Network Structure and Naive Sequential Learning
• Sampled-Data Consensus over Random Networks
• Polarization and Consensus in a Voter Model under Time-Fluctuating Influences
• Opinion dynamics and wisdom under out-group discrimination
• Randomized opinion dynamics over networks: influence estimation from partial observations
• Large order fluctuations, switching, and control in complex networks
• Opinion dynamics on tie-decay networks
• A bistable belief dynamics model for radicalization within sectarian conflict
• Contrarian effects and echo chamber formation in opinion dynamics
• Information Evolution in Complex Networks
• The Social System Identification Problem
• How does homophily shape the topology of a dynamic network?
• Opinion Dynamics on Networks under Correlated Disordered External Perturbations
• Structured networks and coarse-grained descriptions: a dynamical perspective
• Phase Transition of a Non-Linear Opinion Dynamics with Noisy Interactions
• Discerning media bias within a network of political allies and opponents: Disruption by partisans
• Breaking coexistence: Zealotry vs. nonlinear social impact
• Will you infect me with your opinion?
• Opinion Dynamics with Set-Based Confidence: Convergence Criteria and Periodic Solutions
• Optimal selection of the most informative nodes for a noisy DeGroot model with stubborn agents
• Phase transition of the 3-majority opinion dynamics with noisy interactions
• Abrupt transition of the efficient vaccination strategy in a population with heterogeneous fatality rates
• Averaging plus Learning Models and Their Asymptotics
• Accelerated consensus in multi-agent networks via memory of local averages