Quasi-periodic Propagating Signals in the Solar Corona: The Signature of Magnetoacoustic Waves or High-Velocity Upflows?

Abstract

Since the discovery of quasi-periodic propagating oscillations with periods of order three to ten minutes in coronal loops with TRACE and EIT (later with EUVI and EIS), they have been almost universally interpreted as evidence for propagating slow-mode magnetoacoustic (MA) waves in the low-beta coronal environment. We show that this interpretation is not unique. We focus instead on the ubiquitous faint upflows, associated with blue asymmetries of spectral line profiles in footpoint regions of coronal loops, and as faint disturbances propagating along coronal loops in EUV/XR imaging timeseries. The two scenarios are difficult to differentiate using only imaging data, but careful analysis of spectral line profiles indicates that faint upflows are likely responsible for some of the observed quasi-periodic oscillatory signals in the corona. We show that EIS measurements of intensity and velocity oscillations in coronal lines (previously interpreted as direct evidence for propagating waves) are actually accompanied by significant oscillations in the line width that are driven by a quasi-periodically varying component of emission in the blue wing of the line. The faint blue-shifted emission component quasi-periodically modulates the peak intensity and line-centroid of a single Gaussian fit to the profile with the same small amplitudes (respectively a few percent of background intensity, and a few km/s) used to infer the presence of MA waves. Our results indicate that a significant fraction of the quasi-periodicities observed with coronal imagers and spectrographs, previously interpreted as propagating MA waves, are caused by these upflows. The different physical cause for coronal oscillations would significantly impact the prospects of successful coronal seismology using propagating disturbances in coronal loops.

To appear Astrophysical Journal. 14 pages, 13 color figures, 4 movies. High resolution figures and online supporting movies are available at http://tinyurl.com/29s7c4o

References in corpus (12)

• Observing the Roots of Solar Coronal Heating - in the Chromosphere
• Hinode/EIS observations of propagating low-frequency slow magnetoacoustic waves in fan-like coronal loops
• Ubiquitous High Speed Transition Region and Coronal Upflows in the Quiet Sun
• Observing Episodic Coronal Heating Events Rooted in Chromospheric Activity
• 3D Coronal Slow Modes: Towards 3D Seismology
• STEREO Observations of Quasi-Periodically Driven High Velocity Outflows in Polar Plumes
• Propagating waves in polar coronal holes as seen by SUMER and EIS
• Doppler Shift, Intensity, and Density Oscillations Observed with the EUV Imaging Spectrometer on Hinode
• Observations of Solar Doppler Shift Oscillations with the EUV Imaging Spectrometer on Hinode
• A Coherence-Based Approach for Tracking Waves in the Solar Corona
• Using HINODE/EIS to Confirm a Seismologically Inferred Coronal Temperature
• The Impact of New EUV Diagnostics on CME-Related Kinematics

Cited by in corpus (67)

• MHD Waves and Coronal Seismology: an overview of recent results
• Prevalence of Small-scale Jets from the Networks of the Solar Transition Region and Chromosphere
• A Contemporary View of Coronal Heating
• Persistent Doppler shift oscillations observed with HINODE/EIS in the solar corona: spectroscopic signatures of Alfvenic waves and recurring upflows
• Generation of Solar Spicules and Subsequent Atmospheric Heating
• Standing Slow-Mode Waves in Hot Coronal Loops: Observations, Modeling, and Coronal Seismology
• Wave Heating of the Solar Atmosphere
• What can we learn about solar coronal mass ejections, coronal dimmings, and Extreme-Ultraviolet jets through spectroscopic observations?
• Two components of the coronal emission revealed by EUV spectroscopic observations
• Slow-Mode Magnetoacoustic Waves in Coronal Loops
• The Spectroscopic Signature of Quasi-periodic Upflows in Active Region Timeseries
• Observation of High-speed Outflow on Plume-like Structures of the Quiet Sun and Coronal Holes with SDO/AIA
• On The Fourier And Wavelet Analysis Of Coronal Time Series
• MHD Waves in open coronal structures
• Slow magnetosonic waves and fast flows in active region loops
• Frequency-dependent damping in propagating slow magneto-acoustic waves
• Velocity measurements for a solar active region fan loop from Hinode/EIS observations
• Generation of quasi-periodic waves and flows in the solar atmosphere by oscillatory reconnection
• On The Doppler Velocity of Emission Line Profiles Formed in the "Coronal Contraflow" that is the Chromosphere-Corona Mass Cycle
• Omnipresent long-period intensity oscillations in open coronal structures
• Propagating intensity disturbances in polar corona as seen from AIA/SDO
• Propagating Disturbances in Coronal Loops: A Detailed Analysis of Propagation Speeds
• First comparison of wave observations from CoMP and AIA/SDO
• Upflows in the upper solar atmosphere
• Observations and numerical models of solar coronal heating associated with spicules
• Continuous upflows and sporadic downflows observed in active regions
• Coronal Fourier power spectra: implications for coronal seismology and coronal heating
• IRIS observations of short-term variability in moss associated with transient hot coronal loops
• Waves in Solar Coronal Loops
• Propagating Disturbances in The Solar Corona and Spicular Connection
• Three-dimensional MHD modeling of propagating disturbances in fan-like coronal loops
• Observations of quasi-periodic phenomena associated with a large blowout solar jet
• Investigating the Transition Region Explosive Events and Their Relationship to Network Jets
• Spectroscopic Observations of Propagating Disturbances in a Polar Coronal Hole: Evidence of Slow Magneto-acoustic Waves
• Measuring temperature - dependent propagating disturbances in coronal fan loops using multiple SDO/AIA channels and surfing transform technique
• Observed damping of the slow magnetoacoustic mode
• Observational Signatures of Waves and Flows in the Solar Corona
• Forward Modelling of Propagating Slow Waves in Coronal Loops and Their Frequency-Dependent Damping
• Stochastic transients as a source of quasi-periodic processes in the solar atmosphere
• Oscillatory Reconnection of a 2D X-point in a hot coronal plasma
• Effect of Thermal Conductivity, Compressive Viscosity and Radiative Cooling on the Phase Shift of Propagating Slow Waves with and without Heating-Cooling Imbalance
• On the relation between transition region network jets and coronal plumes
• The chromosphere underneath a Coronal Bright Point
• Detection of high frequency oscillations and damping from multi-slit spectroscopic observations of the corona
• Oscillations in active region fan loops: Observations from EIS/{\it Hinode} and AIA/SDO
• Oscillatory reconnection as a plasma diagnostic in the solar corona
• Slow Magneto-acoustic Waves Observed above Quiet-Sun Region in a Dark Cavity
• Recent Observations of Plasma and Alfvenic Wave Energy Injection at the Base of the Fast Solar Wind
• Excitation of flare-induced waves in coronal loops and the effects of radiative cooling
• Apparent and Intrinsic Evolution of Active Region Upflows
• Revisiting the relation between nonthermal line widths and transverse MHD wave amplitudes
• Evolution of active region outflows throughout an active region lifetime
• Periodicities in an active region correlated with Type III radio bursts observed by Parker Solar Probe
• Kinetic Simulation of Slow Magnetosonic Waves and Quasi-periodic Upflows in the Solar Corona
• Kink oscillations of flowing threads in solar prominences
• Observations of upward propagating waves in the transition region and corona above Sunspots
• Widespread Occurrence of High-Velocity Upflows in Solar Active Regions
• The Airborne Infrared Spectrometer: Development, Characterization, and the 21 August 2017 Eclipse Observation
• Reconnection generated plasma flows in the quasi-separatrix layer in localised solar corona
• Dynamics in the transition region beneath active region upflows viewed by IRIS
• Hot prominence spicules launched from turbulent cool solar prominences
• Probable identification of the on-disk counterpart of spicules in Hinode Ca II H observations
• Propagating Oscillations in the Lower Atmosphere under Coronal Holes
• Observational and numerical characterization of a recurrent arc-shaped front propagating along a coronal fan
• Investigating coronal wave energy estimates using synthetic non-thermal line widths
• Resonant Absorption of Kink MHD Waves in Inclined and Asymmetric Coronal Loops
• The independence of oscillatory reconnection periodicity from the initial pulse