How higher-spin gravity surpasses the spin two barrier: no-go theorems versus yes-go examples

Abstract

Aiming at non-experts, we explain the key mechanisms of higher-spin extensions of ordinary gravity. We first overview various no-go theorems for low-energy scattering of massless particles in flat spacetime. In doing so we dress a dictionary between the S-matrix and the Lagrangian approaches, exhibiting their relative advantages and weaknesses, after which we high-light potential loop-holes for non-trivial massless dynamics. We then review positive yes-go results for non-abelian cubic higher-derivative vertices in constantly curved backgrounds. Finally we outline how higher-spin symmetry can be reconciled with the equivalence principle in the presence of a cosmological constant leading to the Fradkin--Vasiliev vertices and Vasiliev's higher-spin gravity with its double perturbative expansion (in terms of numbers of fields and derivatives).

LaTeX, 50 pages, minor changes, many refs added; version accepted for publication in Reviews of Modern Physics

References in corpus (46)

• Asymptotic symmetries of three-dimensional gravity coupled to higher-spin fields
• Nonlinear W(infinity) Algebra as Asymptotic Symmetry of Three-Dimensional Higher Spin Anti-de Sitter Gravity
• An AdS_3 Dual for Minimal Model CFTs
• Chern-Simons Theory with Vector Fermion Matter
• Three-Loop Superfiniteness of N=8 Supergravity
• Symmetries of Holographic Minimal Models
• Gauge Invariant Lagrangians for Free and Interacting Higher Spin Fields. A Review of the BRST formulation
• String Lessons for Higher-Spin Interactions
• Asymptotic W-symmetries in three-dimensional higher-spin gauge theories
• AdS_4/CFT_3 Construction from Collective Fields
• Consistency Conditions on the S-Matrix of Massless Particles
• General trilinear interaction for arbitrary even higher spin gauge fields
• Cubic Vertices for Symmetric Higher-Spin Gauge Fields in $(A)d{S}_d$
• Partition Functions of Holographic Minimal Models
• Unfolding Mixed-Symmetry Fields in AdS and the BMV Conjecture: I. General Formalism
• Holographic dual of free field theory
• Partition functions of higher spin black holes and their CFT duals
• Higher Spin Gravity with Matter in AdS_3 and Its CFT Dual
• Universal Limits on Massless High-Spin Particles
• Constructing the Cubic Interaction Vertex of Higher Spin Gauge Fields
• Consistent couplings between spin-2 and spin-3 massless fields
• Strong obstruction of the Berends-Burgers-van Dam spin-3 vertex
• Higher-Spin Gauge Fields Interacting with Scalars: The Lagrangian Cubic Vertex
• On spin 3 interacting with gravity
• Minimal Model Holography for SO(2N)
• Spin 3 cubic vertices in a frame-like formalism
• Exploring the S-Matrix of Massless Particles
• Aspects of Graviton Detection: Graviton Emission and Absorption by Atomic Hydrogen
• Vector Models in the Singlet Sector at Finite Temperature
• On massive spin 2 electromagnetic interactions
• Interacting Higher Spins and the High Energy Limit of the Bosonic String
• Direct construction of a cubic selfinteraction for higher spin gauge fields
• A Model Independent Ultraviolet Cutoff for Theories with Charged Massive Higher Spin Fields
• Higher Spins and String Interactions
• Higher Spin Theories in AdS_3 and a Gravitational Exclusion Principle
• Intrinsic Cutoff and Acausality for Massive Spin 2 Fields Coupled to Electromagnetism
• An action principle for Vasiliev's four-dimensional higher-spin gravity
• On the AdS Higher Spin / O(N) Vector Model Correspondence: degeneracy of the holographic image
• Nonperturbative gluon and ghost propagators for d=3 Yang-Mills
• Bi-local Model of AdS/CFT and Higher Spin Gravity
• Towards Unifying Structures in Higher Spin Gauge Symmetry
• Higher spin algebras as higher symmetries
• On Singleton Composites in Non-compact WZW Models
• AdS Taub-Nut Space and the O(N) Vector Model on a Squashed 3-Sphere
• Higher Rank Conformal Fields in the $Sp(2M)$ Symmetric Generalized Space-Time
• Gluon mass and freezing of the QCD coupling

Cited by in corpus (200)

• Black holes in three dimensional higher spin gravity: A review
• Light-Front Higher-Spin Theories in Flat Space
• Quartic AdS Interactions in Higher-Spin Gravity from Conformal Field Theory
• Bounding the Space of Holographic CFTs with Chaos
• Fractons, dipole symmetries and curved spacetime
• Higher spin theory in 3-dimensional flat space
• On the uniqueness of higher-spin symmetries in AdS and CFT
• Effective action in a higher-spin background
• Asymptotically flat spacetimes in three-dimensional higher spin gravity
• A generating function for the cubic interactions of higher spin fields
• Cubic interactions of massless higher spins in (A)dS: metric-like approach
• Higher-spin Interactions from CFT: The Complete Cubic Couplings
• Higher-Spin Interactions: four-point functions and beyond
• Quantum Chiral Higher Spin Gravity
• Spinor-Helicity Three-Point Amplitudes from Local Cubic Interactions
• BRST-BV approach to cubic interaction vertices for massive and massless higher-spin fields
• Partially Massless Fields During Inflation
• Towards metric-like higher-spin gauge theories in three dimensions
• Higher Spin Interactions in Four Dimensions: Vasiliev vs. Fronsdal
• Elements of Vasiliev theory
• On the Structure of Quartic Vertices for Massless Higher Spin Fields on Minkowski Background
• Chiral Higher Spin Theories and Self-Duality
• Families of exact solutions to Vasiliev's 4D equations with spherical, cylindrical and biaxial symmetry
• Higher-spin algebras and cubic interactions for simple mixed-symmetry fields in AdS spacetime
• The Boostless Bootstrap: Amplitudes without Lorentz boosts
• Partition function of free conformal higher spin theory
• Generating functions of (partially-)massless higher-spin cubic interactions
• Emergent Models for Gravity: an Overview of Microscopic Models
• BMS Modules in Three Dimensions
• Actions for Self-dual Higher Spin Gravities
• Higher spin black hole entropy in three dimensions
• Elementary particles with continuous spin
• Non-abelian cubic vertices for higher-spin fields in anti-de Sitter space
• Bounds on Amplitudes in Effective Theories with Massive Spinning Particles
• On four-point interactions in massless higher spin theory in flat space
• Gravitational cubic interactions for a simple mixed-symmetry gauge field in AdS and flat backgrounds
• FV-type action for AdS(5) mixed-symmetry fields
• Higher Spin Gravity Amplitudes From Zero-form Charges
• Higher-Spin Theory and Space-Time Metamorphoses
• Massive Higher Spins: Effective Theory and Consistency
• Carrollian and Galilean conformal higher-spin algebras in any dimensions
• Higher-Spin Algebras, Holography and Flat Space
• Superconformal symmetry and maximal supergravity in various dimensions
• Physical content of Quadratic Gravity
• On conformal higher spin wave operators
• On the Non-Local Obstruction to Interacting Higher Spins in Flat Space
• TASI Lectures on the Higher Spin - CFT duality
• From Higher Spins to Strings: A Primer
• Arbitrary spin conformal fields in (A)dS
• Flat space (higher spin) gravity with chemical potentials
• Partially Massless Higher-Spin Theory
• Spin-3 Topological Massive Gravity
• On quantum corrections in higher-spin theory in flat space
• The Other Fermion Compositeness
• Flato-Fronsdal theorem for higher-order singletons
• A note on higher-derivative actions for free higher-spin fields
• One-loop Finiteness of Chiral Higher Spin Gravity
• Generalized Chern-Simons higher-spin gravity theories in three dimensions
• Cubic interaction vertex of higher-spin fields with external electromagnetic field
• Higher Spins and Open Strings: Quartic Interactions
• Extension of the Poincaré group with half-integer spin generators: hypergravity and beyond
• Off-Shell Spinor-Helicity Amplitudes from Light-Cone Deformation Procedure
• Basic introduction to higher-spin theories
• Asymptotically flat structure of hypergravity in three spacetime dimensions
• Massless Scalars and Higher-Spin BMS in Any Dimension
• Interactions in Higher-Spin Gravity: a Holographic Perspective
• Cosmological Shapes of Higher-Spin Gravity
• Rotating Higher Spin Partition Functions and Extended BMS Symmetries
• Conserved higher spin supercurrents for arbitrary spin massless supermultiplets and higher spin superfield cubic interactions
• Higher Spins and Matter Interacting in Dimension Three
• Current Interactions and Holography from the 0-Form Sector of Nonlinear Higher-Spin Equations
• Spinor-Helicity Formalism for Massless Fields in AdS${}_4$
• Lagrangian formulation of the massive higher spin N=1 supermultiplets in $Ad{S}_4$ space
• Current Interactions from the One-Form Sector of Nonlinear Higher-Spin Equations
• Twistor Constructions for Higher-spin Extensions of (Self-dual) Yang-Mills
• Manifest Duality for Partially Massless Higher Spins
• 4D Higher Spin Black Holes with Nonlinear Scalar Fluctuations
• Interaction of supersymmetric nonlinear sigma models with external higher spin superfields via higher spin supercurrents
• Spinor-Helicity Formalism for Massless Fields in AdS${}_4$ II: Potentials
• General Cubic Interacting Vertex for Massless Integer Higher Spin Fields
• Bulk quartic vertices from boundary four-point correlators
• Integrable systems with BMS${}_3$ Poisson structure and the dynamics of locally flat spacetimes
• Off-shell cubic hypermultiplet couplings to $\mathcal{N}=2$ higher spin gauge superfields
• Eikonal Scattering and Asymptotic Superluminality of Massless Higher Spin Fields
• Chiral Tensors of Mixed Young Symmetry
• Higher-spin Yang-Mills, amplitudes and self-duality
• 4D Higher Spin Gravity with Dynamical Two-Form as a Frobenius--Chern--Simons Gauge Theory
• Can Chern-Simons or Rarita-Schwinger be a Volkov-Akulov Goldstone?
• Projectively-Compact Spinor Vertices and Space-Time Spin-Locality in Higher-Spin Theory
• A Calculus for Higher Spin Interactions
• Inflation, Higher Spins and the Swampland
• Unitarity in three-dimensional flat space higher spin theories
• Interactions of Particles with "Continuous Spin" Fields
• Ghost and Tachyon Free Propagation up to spin-3 in Lorentz Invariant Field Theories
• $\mathcal{N}=2$ higher spins: superfield equations of motion, the hypermultiplet supercurrents, and the component structure
• Supersymmetric Reducible Higher-Spin Multiplets in Various Dimensions
• Remarks on a Gauge Theory for Continuous Spin Particles
• The non-linear coupled spin 2 - spin 3 Cotton equation in three dimensions
• A Riccati type PDE for light-front higher helicity vertices
• Old and New No Go Theorems on Interacting Massless Particles in Flat Space
• A Stringy theory in three dimensions and Massive Higher Spins
• Higher Spins in Hyperspace
• New spinorial particle model in tensorial space-time and interacting higher spin fields
• Scalar Fields in 3D Asymptotically Flat Higher-Spin Gravity
• Brief review on higher spin black holes
• ABJ Correlators with Weakly Broken Higher Spin Symmetry
• Critical scaling in the large-$N$ $O(N)$ model in higher dimensions and its possible connection to quantum gravity
• Galilean contractions of $W$-algebras
• Chiral higher-spin holography in flat space: the Flato-Fronsdal theorem and lower-point functions
• Momentum space CFT correlators of non-conserved spinning operators
• A Twistorial Description of the IKKT-Matrix Model
• Cubic-interaction-induced deformations of higher-spin symmetries
• Massive and massless higher spinning particles in odd dimensions
• Helicity decoupling in the massless limit of massive tensor fields
• One-loop effective actions and higher spins. II
• Black holes and thermodynamics - The first half century
• New classes of bi-axially symmetric solutions to four-dimensional Vasiliev higher spin gravity
• Positivity and causal localizability in higher spin quantum field theories
• Supersymmetric Quantum Chiral Higher Spin Gravity
• Action principles for higher and fractional spin gravities
• Holographic Chern-Simons Theories
• On (Un)Broken Higher-Spin Symmetry in Vector Models
• On BF-type higher-spin actions in two dimensions
• Relations between positivity, localization and degrees of freedom: the Weinberg-Witten theorem and the van Dam-Veltman-Zakharov discontinuity
• Quartic interaction vertex in the massive integer higher spin field theory in a constant electromagnetic field
• On Classical Solutions of 4d Supersymmetric Higher Spin Theory
• Factorization of cubic vertices involving three different higher spin fields
• Higher Spin Interacting Quantum Field Theory and Higher Order Conformal Invariant Lagrangians
• Toward Higher Spin dS3/CFT2
• Lectures on Higher Spin Holography
• Hypersymmetric extensions of Maxwell Chern-Simons gravity in (2+1) dimensions
• On Tensorial Spaces and BCFW Recursion Relations for Higher Spin Fields
• Lagrangian formulation of massive fermionic higher spin fields on a constant electromagnetic background
• Covariant Cubic Interacting Vertices for Massless and Massive Integer Higher Spin Fields
• Supersymmetric electric-magnetic duality of hypergravity
• Higher-spin gauge theories in three spacetime dimensions
• Cubic interactions of d4 irreducible massless higher spin fields within BRST approach
• BRST Analysis of the Supersymmetric Higher Spin Field Models
• Hierarchy of Supersymmetric Higher Spin Connections
• Towards A Direct Detection of the Spin of Dark Matter
• Homotopy Algebras in Higher Spin Theory
• Bilocal fields and gravity
• Higher-spin charges in Hamiltonian form. I. Bose fields
• 3d conformal fields with manifest $sl(2,\mathbb{C})$
• Non-relativistic spin-3 symmetries in 2+1 dimensions from expanded/extended Nappi-Witten algebras
• Constraining higher-spin S-matrices
• Gauge invariant and gauge fixed actions for various higher-spin fields from string field theory
• Aspects of Higher-Spin Theory with Fermions
• Unfolded Dynamics Approach and Quantum Field Theory
• Higher Spins in D=2+1
• Emergent dual holographic description as a non-perturbative generalization of the Wilsonian renormalization group
• Analytic meronic black holes, gravitating solitons and higher spins in the Einstein $SU(N)$-Yang-Mills theory
• No-Go Theorems: What Are They Good For?
• Massive Higher-Spin Multiplets and Asymptotic Freedom in Quantum Gravity
• Constraining graviton non-Gaussianity through the CMB bispectra
• On higher spin partition functions
• Hypergravity in five dimensions
• Fermionic higher-spin triplets in AdS
• Selection rules for the decay of a particle into two identical massless particles of any spin
• BRST-BV approach for interacting higher spin fields
• Cubic interaction vertices in higher spin theories
• Entanglement transfer from quantum matter to classical geometry in an emergent holographic dual description of a scalar field theory
• Towards the structure of a cubic interaction vertex for massless integer higher spin fields
• Gauging the higher-spin-like symmetries by the Moyal product
• Cubic interactions for massless and partially massless spin-1 and spin-2 fields
• Fermi-Bose cubic couplings in light-cone field theories
• String Amplitudes and Frame-like Formalism for Higher Spins
• Towards holographic higher-spin interactions: Four-point functions and higher-spin exchange
• Higher Spin Double Field Theory : A Proposal
• Topics in Asymptotic Symmetries and Infrared Effects
• Kinematics of arbitrary spin matter fields in loop quantum gravity
• HS in flat spacetime. YM-like models
• Nonequilibrium thermodynamics perspectives for the monotonicity of the renormalization group flow
• Higher Spin Holography and AdS String Sigma-Model
• Massless chiral fields in six dimensions
• HS Yang-Mills-like models: a review
• Lagrangian formulation of the massive higher spin supermultiplets in three dimensional space-time
• Higher Spins at the Quintic Order: Localization Effect and Simplifications
• Deriving field theories for particles of arbitrary spin with and without supersymmetry
• Unfolded Fierz-Pauli Equations in Three-Dimensional Asymptotically Flat Spacetimes
• $\mathcal{N}=2$ higher-spin theories and harmonic superspace
• Chern-Simons Holography: Boundary Conditions, Contractions and Double Extensions for a Journey Beyond Anti-de Sitter
• Renormalization group flow to effective quantum mechanics at IR in an emergent dual holographic description for spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking
• Higher Spin Fields and Symplectic Geometry
• Contributions to the Muon $g-2$ from a Three-Form Field
• Softness, Polynomial Boundedness and Amplitudes' Positivity
• On Gluing CFT Correlators to Higher-Spin Amplitudes in AdS
• A Generalization of Gravity
• Asymptotic symmetries of three-dimensional higher-spin gravity: the metric approach
• Gravitational anomalies of fermionic higher-spin fields
• Bosonic Higher Spin Gravity in any Dimension with Dynamical Two-Form
• Theories of Massive Gravity in 2+1 Dimensions
• Higher-spin localized shocks
• Comparison between renormalization group derived emergent dual holography and string theory based holographic duality
• Topological Fields in $4d$ Higher Spin Theory
• Toward a mechanism for the emergence of gravity
• Higher Spin Theories from Finsler Geometry
• Higher-Spin Quartic Vertices in AdS5 : a Rectangular Limit
• On hypersymmetry in three dimensioons
• Invariant traces of the flat space chiral higher-spin algebra as scattering amplitudes