On understanding the figures of merit for detection and measurement of x-ray polarization

Abstract

The prospects for accomplishing X-ray polarization measurements appear to have grown in recent years after a more than 35-year hiatus. Unfortunately, this long hiatus has brought with it some confusion over the statistical uncertainties associated with polarization measurements of astronomical sources. The heart of this confusion stems from a misunderstanding (or potential misunderstanding) of a standard figure of merit-the minimum detectable polarization (MDP)-that one of us introduced many years ago. We review the relevant statistics, and quantify the differences between the MDP and the uncertainty of an actual polarization measurement. We discuss the implications for future missions.

5 pages, 2 figures, to be presented at SPIE conference 7732 (paper 13), corrected typos

Cited by in corpus (74)

• Polarized x-rays constrain the disk-jet geometry in the black hole x-ray binary Cygnus X-1
• Design, Construction, and Test of the Gas Pixel Detectors for the IXPE Mission
• Handling Background in IXPE polarimetric data
• XIPE: the X-ray Imaging Polarimetry Explorer
• Light bending scenario for accreting black holes in X-ray polarimetry
• High Energy Polarimetry of Prompt GRB Emission
• PolarLight: a CubeSat X-ray Polarimeter based on the Gas Pixel Detector
• The X-Ray Polarization Signature of Quiescent Magnetars: Effect of Magnetospheric Scattering and Vacuum Polarization
• Gamma-Ray Burst Polarimeter - GAP - aboard the Small Solar Power Sail Demonstrator IKAROS
• Accretion geometry of the neutron star low mass X-ray binary Cyg X-2 from X-ray polarization measurements
• On the Statistical Analysis of X-ray Polarization Measurements
• X-ray Polarization Observations of BL Lacertae
• Prospects for differentiating extended coronal geometries in AGNs with the IXPE mission
• In-flight calibration system of Imaging X-ray Polarimetry Explorer
• The imaging properties of the Gas Pixel Detector as a focal plane polarimeter
• Polarization properties of the weakly magnetized neutron star X-ray binary GS 1826-238 in the high soft state
• On the operation of X-ray polarimeters with a large field of view
• Observation of polarised hard X-ray emission from the Crab by the PoGOLite Pathfinder
• Deep Ensemble Analysis for Imaging X-ray Polarimetry
• Polarimetric Analysis of the Long Duration Gamma Ray Burst GRB 160530A With the Balloon Borne Compton Spectrometer and Imager
• X-ray polarimetry reveals the magnetic field topology on sub-parsec scales in Tycho's supernova remnant
• Analysis of the Data from Compton X-ray Polarimeters which Measure the Azimuthal and Polar Scattering Angles
• IXPE observations of the quintessential wind-accreting X-ray pulsar Vela X-1
• POLARIX: a pathfinder mission of X-ray polarimetry
• The IXPE Instrument Calibration Equipment
• First X-ray polarization measurement confirms the low black-hole spin in LMC X-3
• Optimising a balloon-borne polarimeter in the hard X-ray domain: from the PoGOLite Pathfinder to PoGO+
• A Study of background for IXPE
• Science prospects for SPHiNX - a small satellite GRB polarimetry mission
• Uncovering magnetic turbulence in young supernova remnants with polarized X-ray imaging
• Maximum Likelihood Compton Polarimetry with the Compton Spectrometer and Imager
• Preflight performance studies of the PoGOLite hard X-ray polarimeter
• An observational method for fast stochastic X-ray polarimetry-timing
• Pitfalls of statistics-limited X-ray polarization analysis
• LAMP: a micro-satellite based soft X-ray polarimeter for astrophysics
• High Energy Polarization of Blazars : Detection Prospects
• The gas pixel detector as a solar X-ray polarimeter and imager
• Characterization of scatterers for an active focal plane Compton polarimeter
• Gamma Ray polarimetry; a new window for the non-thermal Universe
• The design and performance of the XL-Calibur anticoincidence shield
• Imaging Polarimeter for a Sub-MeV Gamma-Ray All-Sky Survey using an Electron-Tracking Compton Camera
• Multiband Weighting of X-ray Polarization Data
• A Study of Background Conditions for Sphinx--The Satellite-Borne Gamma-Ray Burst Polarimeter
• Polarized radiation from an accretion shock in accreting millisecond pulsars using exact Compton scattering formalism
• Instrumentation and Future Missions in the Upcoming Era of X-Ray Polarimetry
• X-ray Polarimetry of the accreting pulsar 1A~0535+262 in the supercritical state with PolarLight
• Response of the first POLAR-2 Prototype to Polarized Beams
• Sensitivity of stacked imaging detectors to hard X-ray polarization
• Estimate of the Fermi Large Area Telescope sensitivity to gamma-ray polarization
• Feasibility of Observing Gamma-ray Polarization from Cygnus X-1 Using a CubeSat
• Design and tests of the hard X-ray polarimeter X-Calibur
• Compton Telescopes for Gamma-ray Astrophysics
• A Small Satellite Version of a Broad-band Soft X-ray Polarimeter
• Analysis of the data from photoelectric gas polarimeters
• Prospects of measuring Gamma-ray Burst Polarisation with the Daksha mission
• Polarized multiwavelength emission from pulsar wind - accretion disk interaction in a transitional millisecond pulsar
• X-ray polarimetry-timing
• Modelling polarized X-ray pulses from accreting millisecond pulsars with X-PSI, using different hot spot locations and shapes
• Prospect of polarisation measurements from black hole binaries in their thermal state with a scattering polarimeter
• Polarization properties of X-ray tubes used for Imaging X-ray Polarimetry Explorer calibration
• Gamma-ray Polarimetry of Transient Sources with POLAR
• Gamma-ray detector and mission design simulations
• MeV-GeV Polarimetry with $\gamma \to e^{+}{e}^{-}$: Asserting the Performance of Silicon Strip Detectors-Based Telescopes
• Adding Gamma-ray Polarimetry to the Multi-Messenger Era
• Neural network analysis of X-ray polarimeter data
• General History of X-Ray Polarimetry in Astrophysics
• Gamma-ray burst localisation strategies for the SPHiNX hard X-ray polarimeter
• A Transmissive X-ray Polarimeter Design For Hard X-ray Focusing Telescopes
• Science with a large field-of-view polarization survey: The Large Array Survey Telescope Polarization Node (LAST-P)
• Analysis of Polarimetry Data with Angular Uncertainties
• A significant detection of X-ray Polarization in Sco X-1 with PolarLight and constraints on the corona geometry
• A deep ensemble approach to X-ray polarimetry
• Detectability of Polarized Gamma-ray Emission from Blazar Flares with COSI
• Design and preliminary performance study of the broad-band spectrometer detector for POLAR-2