Three-phase traffic theory and two-phase models with a fundamental diagram in the light of empirical stylized facts

Abstract

Despite the availability of large empirical data sets and the long history of traffic modeling, the theory of traffic congestion on freeways is still highly controversial. In this contribution, we compare Kerner's three-phase traffic theory with the phase diagram approach for traffic models with a fundamental diagram. We discuss the inconsistent use of the term "traffic phase" and show that patterns demanded by three-phase traffic theory can be reproduced with simple two-phase models, if the model parameters are suitably specified and factors characteristic for real traffic flows are considered, such as effects of noise or heterogeneity or the actual freeway design (e.g. combinations of off- and on-ramps). Conversely, we demonstrate that models created to reproduce three-phase traffic theory create similar spatiotemporal traffic states and associated phase diagrams, no matter whether the parameters imply a fundamental diagram in equilibrium or non-unique flow- density relationships. In conclusion, there are different ways of reproducing the empirical stylized facts of spatiotemporal congestion patterns summarized in this contribution, and it appears possible to overcome the controversy by a more precise definition of the scientific terms and a more careful comparison of models and data, considering effects of the measurement process and the right level of detail in the traffic model used.

18 pages in the published article, 13 figures, 2 tables

References in corpus (7)

• Delays, Inaccuracies and Anticipation in Microscopic Traffic Models
• Calibrating Car-Following Models using Trajectory Data: Methodological Study
• Understanding widely scattered traffic flows, the capacity drop, platoons, and times-to-collision as effects of variance-driven time gaps
• Theoretical vs. Empirical Classification and Prediction of Congested Traffic States
• Deterministic approach to microscopic three-phase traffic theory
• On the Controversy around Daganzo's Requiem for and Aw-Rascle's Resurrection of Second-Order Traffic Flow Models
• Synchronized flow and wide moving jams from balanced vehicular traffic

Cited by in corpus (27)

• Traffic experiment reveals the nature of car-following
• Theoretical vs. Empirical Classification and Prediction of Congested Traffic States
• Reconstructing the Traffic State by Fusion of Heterogeneous Data
• Microscopic driving theory with oscillatory congested states: model and empirical verification
• The Intelligent Driver Model with Stochasticity -- New Insights Into Traffic Flow Oscillations
• An Open-Source Microscopic Traffic Simulator
• Continuum modeling of freeway traffic flows: State-of-the-art, challenges and future directions in the era of connected and automated vehicles
• Calibrating Car-Following Models via Bayesian Dynamic Regression
• The comfortable driving model revisited: Traffic phases and phase transitions
• Spatio-temporal propagation of traffic jams in urban traffic networks
• Moment analysis of highway-traffic clearance distribution
• Power laws and phase transitions in heterogenous car following with reaction times
• Classification and Unification of the Microscopic Deterministic Traffic Models with Identical Drivers
• Parsimonious shooting heuristic for trajectory control of connected automated traffic part I: Theoretical analysis with generalized time geography
• Effect of Driver Behavior on Spatiotemporal Congested Traffic Patterns at Highway Bottlenecks in the Framework of Three-Phase Traffic Theory
• Calibration and validation of models describing the spatiotemporal evolution of congested traffic patterns
• Scalable analysis of stop-and-go waves: Representation, measurements and insights
• Empirical analysis and simulation of the evolution concavity of traffic oscillations
• Common Traffic Congestion Features studied in USA, UK, and Germany employing Kerner's Three-Phase Traffic Theory
• Multi-class fundamental diagrams from the Prigogine-Herman-Boltzmann equation
• Bicycle flow dynamics on wide roads: Experiment and modeling
• Cellular automaton model with dynamical 2D speed-gap relation reproduces empirical and experimental features of traffic flow
• Cellular automaton model simulating spatiotemporal patterns, phase transitions and evolution concavity in traffic flow
• A class of multi-phase traffic theories for microscopic, kinetic and continuum traffic models
• Collective patterns of pedestrians interacting with attractions
• Efficient Intersection Control for Minimally Guided Vehicles: A Self-Organised and Decentralized Approach
• Car following behavioral stochasticity analysis and modelling: Perspective from wave travel time