A comparison of frequentist and Bayesian inference: Searching for low-frequency p modes and g modes in Sun-as-a-star data

Abstract

We describe and use two different statistical approaches to try and detect low-frequency solar oscillations in Sun-as-a-star data: a frequentist approach and a Bayesian approach. We have used frequentist statistics to search contemporaneous Sun-as-a-star data for coincident, statistically-prominent features. However, we find that this approach leads to numerous false detections. We have also used Bayesian statistics to search for evidence of low-frequency p modes and g modes in Sun-as-a-star data. We describe how Bayesian statistics can be used to search near-contemporaneous data for coincident prominent features. Near-contemporaneous data were used to circumvent the difficulties in deriving probabilities that occur when common noise is present in the data. We find that the Bayesian approach, which is reliant on the assumptions made when determining the posterior probability, leads to significantly fewer false detections and those that are observed can be discredited using a priori knowledge. Therefore, we have more confidence in the mode candidates found with Bayesian statistics.

16 pages, 11 figures, to be published in MNRAS

References in corpus (10)

• The quest for the solar g modes
• Stochastic excitation of nonradial modes II. Are solar asymptotic gravity modes detectable?
• Frequency, splitting, linewidth and amplitude estimates of low-l p modes of alpha Cen A: analysis of WIRE photometry
• Sensitivity of helioseismic gravity modes to the dynamics of the solar core
• Solar heavy element abundance: constraints from frequency separation ratios of low-degree p modes
• Update on g-mode research
• Influence of Low-Degree High-Order p-Mode Splittings on the Solar Rotation Profile
• On posterior probability and significance level: application to the power spectrum of HD49933 observed by CoRoT
• Bayesian approach for g-mode detection, or how to restrict our imagination
• The visibility of low-frequency solar acoustic modes

Cited by in corpus (4)

• A uniform asteroseismic analysis of 22 solar-type stars observed by Kepler
• Solar Bayesian Analysis Toolkit -- a new Markov chain Monte Carlo IDL code for Bayesian parameter inference
• Detection of l=4 and l=5 modes in 12 years of solar VIRGO-SPM data --- Tests on Kepler observations of 16 Cyg A and B
• Spatial incoherence of solar granulation: a global analysis using BiSON 2B data