On posterior probability and significance level: application to the power spectrum of HD49933 observed by CoRoT

Abstract

We emphasize that the mention of the significance level when rejecting the null hypothesis (H0) which assumes that what is observed is pure noise) can mislead one to think that the H0 hypothesis is unlikely to occur with that significance level. We show that the significance level has nothing to do with the posterior probability of H0 given the observed data set, and that this posterior probability is very much higher than what the significance level naively provides. We use Bayes theorem for deriving the posterior probability of H0 being true assuming an alternative hypothesis H1 that assumes that a mode is present, taking some prior for the mode height, for the mode amplitude and linewidth.We report the posterior probability of H0 for the p modes detected on HD49933 by CoRoT. We conclude that the posterior probability of H0 provide a much more conservative quantification of the mode detection than the significance level. This framework can be applied to any stellar power spectra similar to those obtained for asteroseismology.

6 pages, 5 figures, accepted by A&A, to be published in the CoRoT special isssue

Cited by in corpus (13)

• On detecting the large separation in the autocorrelation of stellar oscillation times series
• Oscillation mode frequencies of 61 main sequence and subgiant stars observed by Kepler
• The Octave (Birmingham - Sheffield Hallam) automated pipeline for extracting oscillation parameters of solar-like main-sequence stars
• Seismic and spectroscopic characterization of the solar-like pulsating CoRoT target HD 49385
• A fresh look at the seismic spectrum of HD49933: analysis of 180 days of CoRoT photometry
• Probing the temperature gradient in the core boundary layer of stars with gravito-inertial modes: the case of KIC7760680
• Convective boundary mixing in low- and intermediate-mass stars I. Core properties from pressure-mode asteroseismology
• Estimating the p-mode frequencies of the solar twin 18 Sco
• Detection of l=4 and l=5 modes in 12 years of solar VIRGO-SPM data --- Tests on Kepler observations of 16 Cyg A and B
• Deciphering stellar chorus: apollinaire, a Python 3 module for Bayesian peakbagging in helio- and asteroseismology
• Observational Aspects of Galactic Accretion at Redshift 3.3
• A comparison of frequentist and Bayesian inference: Searching for low-frequency p modes and g modes in Sun-as-a-star data
• Periodicity search as a tool for disentangling the contaminated colour light curve of CoRoT 102781750