Self-organization without conservation: Are neuronal avalanches generically critical?

Abstract

Recent experiments on cortical neural networks have revealed the existence of well-defined avalanches of electrical activity. Such avalanches have been claimed to be generically scale-invariant -- i.e. power-law distributed -- with many exciting implications in Neuroscience. Recently, a self-organized model has been proposed by Levina, Herrmann and Geisel to justify such an empirical finding. Given that (i) neural dynamics is dissipative and (ii) there is a loading mechanism "charging" progressively the background synaptic strength, this model/dynamics is very similar in spirit to forest-fire and earthquake models, archetypical examples of non-conserving self-organization, which have been recently shown to lack true criticality. Here we show that cortical neural networks obeying (i) and (ii) are not generically critical; unless parameters are fine tuned, their dynamics is either sub- or super-critical, even if the pseudo-critical region is relatively broad. This conclusion seems to be in agreement with the most recent experimental observations. The main implication of our work is that, if future experimental research on cortical networks were to support that truly critical avalanches are the norm and not the exception, then one should look for more elaborate (adaptive/evolutionary) explanations, beyond simple self-organization, to account for this.

28 pages, 11 figures, regular paper

References in corpus (9)

• Critical phenomena in complex networks
• Dynamical synapses causing self-organized criticality in neural networks
• Does the 1/f frequency-scaling of brain signals reflect self-organized critical states?
• Self-Organized Criticality model for Brain Plasticity
• The Physics of Living Neural Networks
• Confirming and extending the hypothesis of universality in sandpiles
• Absorbing states and elastic interfaces in random media: two equivalent descriptions of self-organized criticality
• Periodicity and criticality in the Olami-Feder-Christensen model of earthquakes
• Sticky grains do not change the universality class of isotropic sandpiles

Cited by in corpus (40)

• Criticality in the brain: A synthesis of neurobiology, models and cognition
• Griffiths phases and the stretching of criticality in brain networks
• Power laws and Self-Organized Criticality in Theory and Nature
• Landau-Ginzburg theory of cortex dynamics: Scale-free avalanches emerge at the edge of synchronization
• Evidence for quasicritical brain dynamics
• Self-organization toward criticality by synaptic plasticity
• Feedback mechanisms for self-organization to the edge of a phase transition
• Universality in driven open quantum matter
• Homeostatic plasticity and external input shape neural network dynamics
• Growing Critical: Self-Organized Criticality in a Developing Neural System
• Hybrid-type synchronization transitions: where marginal coherence, scale-free avalanches, and bistability live together
• Time-series thresholding and the definition of avalanche size
• Synaptic balance due to homeostatically self-organized quasicritical dynamics
• Self-organized critical balanced networks: a unified framework
• Theoretical foundations of studying criticality in the brain
• Self-organized bistability and its possible relevance for brain dynamics
• Can dynamical synapses produce true self-organized criticality?
• Self-Organized Supercriticality and Oscillations in Networks of Stochastic Spiking Neurons
• Single-Neuron Criticality Optimizes Analog Dendritic Computation
• Signal integration enhances the dynamic range in neuronal systems
• Correlations Induced by Depressing Synapses in Critically Self-Organized Networks with Quenched Dynamics
• Critical neural networks with short and long term plasticity
• Critical Avalanches and Subsampling in Map-based Neural Networks
• A bifurcation integrates information from many noisy ion channels
• Chaos and correlated avalanches in excitatory neural networks with synaptic plasticity
• Non-normality, reactivity, and intrinsic stochasticity in neural dynamics: a non-equilibrium potential approach
• Hydrodynamic stabilization of self-organized criticality in a driven Rydberg gas
• Cooperation, competition and the emergence of criticality in communities of adaptive systems
• Homeostatic Criticality in Neuronal Networks
• Rounding of abrupt phase transitions in brain networks
• Unstable Dynamics, Nonequilibrium Phases and Criticality in Networked Excitable Media
• Information processing occurs via critical avalanches in a model of the primary visual cortex
• Coexistence of scale invariant and rhythmic behavior in self-organized criticality
• Physics of Psychophysics: two coupled square lattices of spiking neurons have huge dynamic range at criticality
• Controlling excitation avalanches in driven Rydberg gases
• Discrete scaling and criticality in a chain of adaptive excitable integrators
• Optimal input reverberation and homeostatic self-organization towards the edge of synchronization
• Topology of the Visibility Graph of Sandpiles
• Sandpile cascades on oscillator networks: the BTW model meets Kuramoto
• Defining and finding lifelike entities with a lazy filter