Numerical versus analytical accuracy of the formulas for light propagation

Abstract

Numerical integration of the differential equations of light propagation in the Schwarzschild metric shows that in some situations relevant for practical observations the well-known post-Newtonian solution for light propagation has an error up to 16 microarcsecond. The aim of this work is to demonstrate this fact, identify the reason for this error and to derive an analytical formula accurate at the level of 1 microarcsecond as needed for high-accuracy astrometric projects (e.g., Gaia). An analytical post-post-Newtonian solution for the light propagation for both Cauchy and boundary problems is given for the Schwarzschild metric augmented by the PPN and post-linear parameters $\beta$, $\gamma$ and $\epsilon$. Using analytical upper estimates of each term we investigate which post-post-Newtonian terms may play a role for an observer in the solar system at the level of 1 microarcsecond and conclude that only one post-post-Newtonian term remains important for this numerical accuracy. In this way, an analytical solution for the boundary problem for light propagation is derived. That solution contains terms of both post-Newtonian and post-post-Newtonian order, but is valid for the given numerical level of 1 microarcsecond. The derived analytical solution has been verified using the results of a high-accuracy numerical integration of differential equations of light propagation and found to be correct at the level well below 1 microarcsecond for arbitrary observer situated within the solar system. Furthermore, the origin of the post-post-Newtonian terms relevant for the microarcsecond accuracy is elucidated. We demonstrate that these terms result from an inadequate choice of the impact parameter in the standard post-Newtonian formulas.

References in corpus (1)

• General post-Minkowskian expansion of time transfer functions

Cited by in corpus (31)

• Strong-field Gravity Tests with the Double Pulsar
• Relativistic formulation of coordinate light time, Doppler and astrometric observables up to the second post-Minkowskian order
• 2PN Light Propagation in the Scalar-Tensor Theory: an $N$-Point-Masses Case
• The Second Post-Newtonian Light Propagation and Its Astrometric Measurement in the Solar System
• Direction of light propagation to order G^2 in static, spherically symmetric spacetimes: a new derivation
• Scalar-tensor propagation of light in the inner solar system at the millimetric level
• Gravitational signal propagation in the Double Pulsar studied with the MeerKAT telescope
• Time Transfer functions as a way to validate light propagation solutions for space astrometry
• Light propagation in the gravitational field of N arbitrarily moving bodies in 1PN approximation for high-precision astrometry
• New method for determining the light travel time in static, spherically symmetric spacetimes. Calculation of the terms of order $G^3$
• Time transfer functions in Schwarzschild-like metrics in the weak-field limit: A unified description of Shapiro and lensing effects
• Light propagation in the gravitational field of N arbitrarily moving bodies in the 1.5PN approximation for high-precision astrometry
• Light propagation in the gravitational field of one arbitrarily moving pointlike body in the 2PN approximation
• Post-Newtonian light propagation in Kerr-Newman spacetime
• Relativistic propagation and frame dragging time delay in the timing of a pulsar orbiting the supermassive black hole SgrA*
• A generalized lens equation for light deflection in weak gravitational fields
• Light propagation in 2PN approximation in the field of one moving monopole: I. Initial value problem
• Probing the vector charge of Sagittarius A* with pulsar timing
• Kerr-Newman black hole lensing of relativistic massive particles in the weak field limit
• Light propagation in 2PN approximation in the field of one moving monopole II. Boundary value problem
• Time delay in the quadrupole field of a body at rest in 2PN approximation
• Light propagation in 2PN approximation in the monopole and quadrupole field of a body at rest: Initial value problem
• Post-linear metric of a compact source of matter
• The post-linear Schwarzschild solution in harmonic coordinates: elimination of structure-dependent terms
• Gravitational wave effects on astrometric observables
• Total light deflection in the gravitational field of an axisymmetric body at rest with full mass and spin multipole structure
• Post-Minkowskian solution for the small-deflection motion of test particles in Kerr-Newman spacetime
• 2PN/RM gauge invariance in Brans-Dicke-like scalar-tensor theories
• Parameterized second post-Newtonian framework with conservation Laws
• Light deflection in binary stars
• On the efficient computation of the quadrupole light deflection