Collapse Barriers and Halo Abundance: Testing the Excursion Set Ansatz

Abstract

Our heuristic understanding of the abundance of dark matter halos centers around the concept of a density threshold, or "barrier", for gravitational collapse. If one adopts the ansatz that regions of the linearly evolved density field smoothed on mass scale M with an overdensity that exceeds the barrier will undergo gravitational collapse into halos of mass M, the corresponding abundance of such halos can be estimated simply as a fraction of the mass density satisfying the collapse criterion divided by the mass M. The key ingredient of this ansatz is therefore the functional form of the collapse barrier as a function of mass M or, equivalently, of the variance sigma^2(M). Several such barriers based on the spherical, Zel'dovich, and ellipsoidal collapse models have been extensively discussed. Using large scale cosmological simulations, we show that the relation between the linear overdensity and the mass variance for regions that collapse to form halos by the present epoch resembles expectations from dynamical models of ellipsoidal collapse. However, we also show that using such a collapse barrier with the excursion set ansatz predicts a halo mass function inconsistent with that measured directly in cosmological simulations. This inconsistency demonstrates a failure of the excursion set ansatz as a physical model for halo collapse. We discuss implications of our results for understanding the collapse epoch for halos as a function of mass, and avenues for improving consistency between analytical models for the collapse epoch and the results of cosmological simulations.

Version accepted by ApJ, scheduled for May 2009, v696. High-res version available at http://kicp.uchicago.edu/~brant/astro-ph/excursion_set_ansatz/robertson_excursion_set_ansatz.pdf

References in corpus (15)

• Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
• Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Likelihoods and Parameters from the WMAP data
• The shape of the SDSS DR5 galaxy power spectrum
• Halo Assembly Bias in Hierarchical Structure Formation
• The Excursion Set Theory of Halo Mass Functions, Halo Clustering, and Halo Growth
• The dependence of dark halo clustering on the formation epoch and the concentration parameter
• On Halo Formation Times and Assembly Bias
• The virialized mass of dark matter haloes
• Environmental Dependence of Cold Dark Matter Halo Formation
• The Clustering of Massive Halos
• Environmental dependence in the ellipsoidal collapse model
• Dark matter halo abundances, clustering and assembly histories at high redshift
• Why does the clustering of haloes depend on their formation history
• The clustering of the first galaxy halos

Cited by in corpus (86)

• The Large Scale Bias of Dark Matter Halos: Numerical Calibration and Model Tests
• Large-Scale Galaxy Bias
• Cosmological Constraints from the SDSS maxBCG Cluster Catalog
• Haloes gone MAD: The Halo-Finder Comparison Project
• Galaxy Formation Theory
• Simulating the Universe with MICE: The abundance of massive clusters
• Mass Function Predictions Beyond LCDM
• Precision measurement of the local bias of dark matter halos
• Constraining primordial non-Gaussianity with future galaxy surveys
• Large-scale non-Gaussian mass function and halo bias: tests on N-body simulations
• Cluster Galaxy Dynamics and the Effects of Large Scale Environment
• The Halo Mass Function from Excursion Set Theory. II. The Diffusing Barrier
• The cosmic history of the spin of dark matter haloes within the large scale structure
• ZOMG-I. How the cosmic web inhibits halo growth and generates assembly bias
• A generalized local ansatz and its effect on halo bias
• The Halo Mass Function from Excursion Set Theory. III. Non-Gaussian Fluctuations
• Excursion set peaks: a self-consistent model of dark halo abundances and clustering
• Large-scale assembly bias of dark matter halos
• Dark-Matter Decays and Self-Gravitating Halos
• Halo bias in Lagrangian Space: Estimators and theoretical predictions
• Universal at last? The splashback mass function of dark matter halos
• Primordial non-Gaussianity in the large scale structure of the Universe
• Toward a Universal Formulation of the Halo Mass Function
• Ellipsoidal halo finders and implications for models of triaxial halo formation
• The spatial and velocity bias of linear density peaks and proto-haloes in the Lambda cold dark matter cosmology
• Implications for Primordial Non-Gaussianity (f_NL) from weak lensing masses of high-z galaxy clusters
• The Hunt for Primordial Interactions in the Large Scale Structures of the Universe
• Non-Gaussianity from Large-Scale Structure Surveys
• Local stochastic non-Gaussianity and N-body simulations
• Excursion Set Halo Mass Function and Bias in a Stochastic Barrier Model of Ellipsoidal Collapse
• The Bias and Mass Function of Dark Matter Halos in Non-Markovian Extension of the Excursion Set Theory
• On Ellipsoidal Collapse and Primordial Black-Hole Formation
• Velocity bias in the distribution of dark matter halos
• The Impact of Theoretical Uncertainties in the Halo Mass Function and Halo Bias on Precision Cosmology
• An Improved Calculation of the Non-Gaussian Halo Mass Function
• Bias deconstructed: Unravelling the scale dependence of halo bias using real space measurements
• The formation of CDM haloes I: Collapse thresholds and the ellipsoidal collapse model
• AMBER: A Semi-numerical Abundance Matching Box for the Epoch of Reionization
• Testing the imprint of non-standard cosmologies on void profiles using Monte Carlo random walks
• A local bias approach to the clustering of discrete density peaks
• The rise and fall of a challenger: the Bullet Cluster in $\Lambda$ Cold Dark Matter simulations
• Testing spherical evolution for modelling void abundances
• An improved model of HII bubbles during the epoch of reionization
• Self-consistency of the Excursion Set Approach
• Measuring nonlocal Lagrangian peak bias
• Statistics of Dark Matter Halos from the Excursion Set Approach
• Computation of the Halo Mass Function Using Physical Collapse Parameters: Application to Non-Standard Cosmologies
• The locations of halo formation and the peaks formalism
• The Influence of Galaxy Formation Physics on Weak Lensing Tests of General Relativity
• The formation of CDM haloes II: collapse time and tides
• Some assembly required: assembly bias in massive dark matter halos
• The Origin of Dark Matter Halo Profiles
• When do cosmic peaks, filaments or walls merge? A theory of critical events in a multi-scale landscape
• The Total Mass of Dark Matter Haloes
• The universal multiplicity function: counting halos and voids
• Non-Gaussian Halo Mass Function and Non-Spherical Halo Collapse: Theory vs. Simulations
• Dark Matter Halos from the Inside Out
• Optical Galaxy Clusters in the Deep Lens Survey
• Halo Mass Definition and Multiplicity Function
• Alignments of the Galaxies in and around the Virgo Cluster with the Local Velocity Shear
• Phenomenology of BAO evolution from Lagrangian to Eulerian Space
• Excursion set peaks in energy as a model for haloes
• Peaks and dips in Gaussian random fields: a new algorithm for the shear eigenvalues, and the excursion set theory
• Excursion Set Theory for Correlated Random Walks
• Cosmology with Galaxy Clusters: Systematic Effects in the Halo Mass Function
• Lagrangian Statistics of Dark Halos in a LCDM Cosmology
• Statistics of Dark Matter Halos in the Excursion Set Peak Framework
• Dark matter halo assembly bias: environmental dependence in the non-Markovian excursion set theory
• Consistency relations for the Lagrangian halo bias and their implications
• Constrained simulations and excursion sets: understanding the risks and benefits of `genetically modified' haloes
• Constraining the Neutrino Mass with the Drifting Coefficient of the Field Cluster Mass Function
• Evaluating backreaction with the ellipsoidal collapse model
• Scale-dependent bias from an inflationary bispectrum: the effect of a stochastic moving barrier
• Halo Profile Evolution and Velocity Bias
• The Diffusion Coefficient of the Splashback Mass Function as a Probe of Cosmology
• Mass assembly history of dark matter halos in the light of $H_0$ tension
• Evolution of the Deterministic Collapse Barrier of the Field Clusters as a Probe of Cosmology
• A spherical hydrodynamical model of cosmic voids in ΛCDM and beyond
• Accurate halo mass functions from the simplest excursion set theory
• Voids and Halos in Voids statistics as a probe of the Expansion History of the Universe
• Mean maps for cosmic web structures in cosmological initial conditions
• The Splashback Mass Function in the Presence of Massive Neutrinos
• Statistical Properties of Supercluster-Like Filaments from Cosmological Simulations
• Excursion Sets with a "Perfect" Collapse Model
• Slicing cluster mass functions with a Bayesian razor
• Segmenting proto-halos with vision transformers