Cosmographic Hubble fits to the supernova data

Abstract

The Hubble relation between distance and redshift is a purely cosmographic relation that depends only on the symmetries of a FLRW spacetime, but does not intrinsically make any dynamical assumptions. This suggests that it should be possible to estimate the parameters defining the Hubble relation without making any dynamical assumptions. To test this idea, we perform a number of inter-related cosmographic fits to the legacy05 and gold06 supernova datasets. Based on this supernova data, the "preponderance of evidence" certainly suggests an accelerating universe. However we would argue that (unless one uses additional dynamical and observational information) this conclusion is not currently supported "beyond reasonable doubt". As part of the analysis we develop two particularly transparent graphical representations of the redshift-distance relation -- representations in which acceleration versus deceleration reduces to the question of whether the relevant graph slopes up or down. Turning to the details of the cosmographic fits, three issues in particular concern us: First, the fitted value for the deceleration parameter changes significantly depending on whether one performs a chi^2 fit to the luminosity distance, proper motion distance or other suitable distance surrogate. Second, the fitted value for the deceleration parameter changes significantly depending on whether one uses the traditional redshift variable z, or what we shall argue is on theoretical grounds an improved parameterization y=z/(1+z). Third, the published estimates for systematic uncertainties are sufficiently large that they certainly impact on, and to a large extent undermine, the usual purely statistical tests of significance. We conclude that the supernova data should be treated with some caution.

28 pages, 4 figures

References in corpus (26)

• Type Ia Supernova Discoveries at z>1 From the Hubble Space Telescope: Evidence for Past Deceleration and Constraints on Dark Energy Evolution
• The Cosmological Parameters 2006
• Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (Particle Data Group mini-review)
• The Supernova Legacy Survey: Measurement of Omega_M, Omega_Lambda and w from the First Year Data Set
• New Hubble Space Telescope Discoveries of Type Ia Supernovae at z > 1: Narrowing Constraints on the Early Behavior of Dark Energy
• Statefinder -- a new geometrical diagnostic of dark energy
• Observational Constraints on the Nature of the Dark Energy: First Cosmological Results from the ESSENCE Supernova Survey
• Improved Distances to Type Ia Supernovae with Multicolor Light Curve Shapes: MLCS2k2
• Jerk, snap, and the cosmological equation of state
• Cosmography: Cosmology without the Einstein equations
• A kinematical approach to dark energy studies
• A theoretician's analysis of the supernova data and the limitations in determining the nature of dark energy
• Cosmological parameters from supernova observations: A critical comparison of three data sets
• Observational constraints on low redshift evolution of dark energy: How consistent are different observations?
• Distance measures in cosmology
• Precision Cosmology? Not Just Yet
• A Local Hubble Bubble from SNe Ia?
• The Hubble series: Convergence properties and redshift variables
• The Luminosity Distance, the Equation of State, and the Geometry of the Universe
• What Do We Really Know About Cosmic Acceleration?
• Tension and Systematics in the Gold06 SnIa Dataset
• Expansion, Geometry, and Gravity
• Bayesian analysis of Friedmannless cosmologies
• Accelerating cosmologies tested by distance measures
• No evidence for Dark Energy Metamorphosis ?
• Cosmography: Extracting the Hubble series from the supernova data

Cited by in corpus (73)

• Extended Gravity Cosmography
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• $H_0$ from cosmic chronometers and Type Ia supernovae, with Gaussian Processes and the novel Weighted Polynomial Regression method
• Cosmography and constraints on the equation of state of the Universe in various parametrizations
• Cosmographic analysis of the equation of state of the universe through Padé approximations
• Cosmographic bounds on the cosmological deceleration-acceleration transition redshift in $f(\mathcal{R})$ gravity
• Accelerated Expansion of the Universe in Non-minimally Coupled Gravity
• Cosmography in $f(Q)$ gravity
• High-redshift cosmography: auxiliary variables versus Padé polynomials
• General Cosmography Model with Spatial Curvature
• Cosmology with hybrid expansion law: scalar field reconstruction of cosmic history and observational constraints
• Cosmographic analysis with Chebyshev polynomials
• An improved model-independent assessment of the late-time cosmic expansion
• Light propagation in statistically homogeneous and isotropic dust universes
• Cosmographic Constraints and Cosmic Fluids
• Light propagation in statistically homogeneous and isotropic universes with general matter content
• High-Redshift Cosmography
• Cosmographic reconstruction of $f(\mathcal{T})$ cosmology
• Updated constraints on $f(\mathcal{R})$ gravity from cosmography
• Probing kinematics and fate of the Universe with linearly time-varying deceleration parameter
• Measurements of $H_0$ and reconstruction of the dark energy properties from a model-independent joint analysis
• Cosmography beyond standard candles and rulers
• Connecting early and late universe by $f(R)$ gravity
• Could the cosmic acceleration be transient? A cosmographic evaluation
• Kinematic constraints beyond $z\simeq 0$ using calibrated GRB correlations
• What do we know about cosmography
• Global dynamics and inflationary center manifold and slow-roll approximants
• Geodesics and the magnitude-redshift relation on cosmologically symmetric Finsler spacetimes
• Cosmography of f(R) - brane cosmology
• Observational Constraints and Cosmological Implications of Scalar-Tensor $f(R,T)$ Gravity
• Model-Independent Constraints on Lorentz Invariance Violation via the Cosmographic Approach
• Conformally Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker cosmologies
• Constraints on the transition redshift from the calibrated Gamma-ray Burst $E_{\mathrm{p}}$-$E_{\mathrm{iso}}$ correlation
• Cosmographic analysis of redshift drift
• New Generalizations of Cosmography Inspired by the Pade Approximant
• Cosmographic view on the $H_0$ and ${\sigma }_8$ tensions
• Model- and calibration-independent test of cosmic acceleration
• BAO cosmography
• Detecting the cosmic acceleration with current data
• A cosmographic analysis of the transition to acceleration using SN-Ia and BAO
• Cosmological dark energy effects from entanglement
• Exploring new physics in the late Universe's expansion through non-parametric inference
• Observational Constraints on Growth Index with Cosmography
• Testing Lambda and the Limits of Cosmography with the Union2.1 Supernova Compilation
• Diagnostic and Comparative Analysis of Dark Energy Models with $q(z)$ Parametrizations
• Recovering $\Lambda$CDM Model From a Cosmographic Study
• Model-Independent Determination of $H_0$ and ${\Omega }_{K,0}$ using Time-Delay Galaxy Lenses and Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Late Time Acceleration of the 3-Space in a Higher Dimensional Steady State Universe in Dilaton Gravity
• On the luminosity distance and the epoch of acceleration
• Curvature dark energy reconstruction through different cosmographic distance definitions
• Time variable $\Lambda$ and the accelerating Universe
• Angular distribution of cosmological parameters as a probe of inhomogeneities: a kinematic parametrisation
• Scale-Free model for governing universe dynamics
• Extended Uncertainty Principle: A Deeper Insight into the Hubble Tension?
• ΛCDM suitably embedded in f(R) with a non-minimal coupling to matter
• From Barthel Randers Kropina Geometries to the Accelerating Universe: A Brief Review of Recent Advances in Finslerian Cosmology
• Cosmography of the minimally extended Varying Speed of Light Model
• Non-perturbative results for the luminosity and area distances
• Modeling dark energy through an Ising fluid with network interactions
• Cosmic Acceleration from Causal Backreaction in a Smoothly Inhomogeneous Universe
• Constraining the runaway dilaton and quintessential dark energy
• Perturbative treatment of the luminosity distance
• Cosmic Acceleration and a New Concordance from Causal Backreaction
• Can MONDian vector theories explain the cosmic speed up ?
• Cosmic Acceleration from Causal Backreaction with Recursive Nonlinearities
• Density perturbation in the models reconstructed from jerk parameter
• Observational tests of the conformal osculating Barthel-Kropina cosmological model
• Characterising Dark Energy through supernovae
• Bounding the Hubble flow in terms of the w parameter
• Dynamical analysis of the redshift drift in FLRW universes
• Effects of dynamical friction on perturbations for evolving dark energy
• Perturbations In Some Dark Energy Models
• The spacetime geodesy of perfect fluid spheres