On the dangers of using the growth equation on large scales in the Newtonian gauge

Abstract

We examine the accuracy of the growth equation $\ddot{\delta }+2H\dot{\delta }-4\pi G\rho \delta =0$, which is ubiquitous in the cosmological literature, in the context of the Newtonian gauge. By comparing the growth predicted by this equation to a numerical solution of the linearized Einstein equations in the $\Lambda$CDM scenario, we show that while this equation is a reliable approximation on small scales ($k\gtrsim$h Mpc${}^{-1}$), it can be disastrously inaccurate ($\sim 10^4$) on larger scales in this gauge. We propose a modified version of the growth equation for the Newtonian gauge, which while preserving the simplicity of the original equation, provides considerably more accurate results. We examine the implications of the failure of the growth equation on a few recent studies, aimed at discriminating general relativity from modified gravity, which use this equation as a starting point. We show that while the results of these studies are valid on small scales, they are not reliable on large scales or high redshifts, if one works in the Newtonian gauge. Finally, we discuss the growth equation in the synchronous gauge and show that the corrections to the Poisson equation are exactly equivalent to the difference between the overdensities in the synchronous and Newtonian gauges.

arXiv commentAdded refs and further discussion of gauge issues. Results and conclusions unchanged. Version accepted at PRD

References in corpus (15)

• Dynamics of dark energy
• Cosmological Perturbation Theory in the Synchronous and Conformal Newtonian Gauges
• Cosmological Perturbation Theory in the Synchronous vs. Conformal Newtonian Gauge
• Cosmic Growth History and Expansion History
• A discriminating probe of gravity at cosmological scales
• The first WIMPy halos
• Classical evolution and quantum generation in generalized gravity theories including string corrections and tachyon: Unified analyses
• On the growth of linear perturbations
• Cosmological perturbations in a generalized gravity including tachyonic condensation
• Next Generation Redshift Surveys and the Origin of Cosmic Acceleration
• Perturbations in cosmologies with a scalar field and a perfect fluid
• Voids of dark energy
• A new perspective on the relation between dark energy perturbations and the late-time ISW effect
• A new standard model of the universe
• Stochastic contribution to the growth factor in the LCDM model

Cited by in corpus (25)

• f(T) teleparallel gravity and cosmology
• Cosmological perturbations in f(T) gravity
• f(T) gravity mimicking dynamical dark energy. Background and perturbation analysis
• Theoretical Priors On Modified Growth Parametrisations
• Scale-dependent bias from primordial non-Gaussianity in general relativity
• Viscous dark matter growth in (neo-)Newtonian cosmology
• New Parametrization for the Scale Dependent Growth Function in General Relativity
• Characterizing the linear growth rate of cosmological density perturbations in an f(R) model
• Newtonian versus relativistic cosmology
• Consistency of LCDM with Geometric and Dynamical Probes
• Duel of cosmological screening lengths
• Dark energy homogeneity in general relativity: Are we applying it correctly?
• Parametrization for the Scale Dependent Growth in Modified Gravity
• Testing General Relativity Using the Evolution of Linear Bias
• Decaying dark matter mimicking time-varying dark energy
• Perturbed dark energy: classical scalar field versus tachyon
• The exact analytical solution of the linear structure growth rate in LCDM cosmology and its cosmological applications
• Dynamical dark energy models with singularities in the view of the forthcoming results of the growth observations
• Dark sector interactions in the $w\to -1$ limit: velocity locking in pure momentum exchange models
• Dispersion in the growth of matter perturbations
• CDM and Baryons as Distinct Fluids in a Linear Approximation for the Growth of Structure
• $\Lambda$CDM-like models with future singularities
• Probing beyond-Horndeski gravity on ultra-large scales
• Scale-dependent perturbations finally detectable by future galaxy surveys and their contribution to cosmological model selection
• Cosmic magnification in beyond-Horndeski gravity