Failure of the work-Hamiltonian connection for free energy calculations

Abstract

Extensions of statistical mechanics are routinely being used to infer free energies from the work performed over single-molecule nonequilibrium trajectories. A key element of this approach is the ubiquitous expression dW/dt=\partial H(x,t)/ \partial t which connects the microscopic work W performed by a time-dependent force on the coordinate x with the corresponding Hamiltonian H(x,t) at time t. Here we show that this connection, as pivotal as it is, cannot be used to estimate free energy changes. We discuss the implications of this result for single-molecule experiments and atomistic molecular simulations and point out possible avenues to overcome these limitations.

References in corpus (2)

• A nonequilibrium equality for free energy differences
• Work probability distribution in systems driven out of equilibrium

Cited by in corpus (34)

• Stochastic thermodynamics, fluctuation theorems, and molecular machines
• Colloquium. Quantum Fluctuation Relations: Foundations and Applications
• Entropy-Based Formulation of Thermodynamics in Arbitrary Quantum Evolution
• Statistics of the dissipated energy in driven single-electron transitions
• Fluctuations in heat engines
• Comment on: Failure of the Work-Hamiltonian Connection for Free-Energy Calculations [Phys Rev Lett 100, 020601 (2008), arXiv:0704.0761]
• Comment on "Failure of the work-Hamiltonian connection for free-energy calculations" by Jose M. G. Vilar and J. Miguel Rubi
• Quantum mechanical work
• Vanishing efficiency of speeded-up quantum Otto engines
• Exploring quantum thermodynamics with NMR
• The Work-Hamiltonian Connection and the Usefulness of the Jarzynski Equality for Free Energy Calculations
• Stochastic Thermodynamics of a Particle in a Box
• Exact Nonequilibrium Work Generating Function for a Small Classical System
• A Parallel-pulling Protocol for Free-Energy Evaluation
• Dissipated work and fluctuation relations for non-equilibrium single-electron transitions
• Comment on "On the Crooks fluctuation theorem and the Jarzynski equality" [J. Chem. Phys. 129, 091101 (2008)]
• Quantum work: Reconciling quantum mechanics and thermodynamics
• Identifying weak values with intrinsic dynamical properties in Modal theories
• Statistical work-energy theorems in deterministic dynamics
• Fluctuation theorems for genuine quantum mechanical regimes
• Work, Heat and Internal Energy in Open Quantum Systems: A Comparison of Four Approaches from the Autonomous System Framework
• Electromagnetic gauge-freedom and work
• First Law of Quantum Thermodynamics in a Driven Open Two-Level System
• A Review of the System-Intrinsic Nonequilibrium Thermodynamics in Extended Space (MNEQT) with Applications
• A constraint on local definitions of quantum internal energy
• Ab initio relaxation times and time-dependent Hamiltonians within the steepest-entropy-ascent quantum thermodynamic framework
• Energy additivity as a requirement for universal quantum thermodynamical frameworks
• Inconsistency of the non-standard definition of work
• Thermodynamics of fluctuations in small systems interacting with the environment
• Dynamic dependence of nonequilibrium work limits the validity of the Jarzynski Equality
• Work distributions in the T=0 Random Field Ising Model
• Bohmian Mechanics as a Practical Tool
• Work fluctuation theorems and free energy from kinetic theory
• Comment on: Inconsistency of the nonstandard definition of work