2 papers
cs.DL2026
Guiding LLM Peer Reviewers: The Impact of Score Anchors on Review Evidence and Accuracy
Judita Preiss, Yunhan Yang
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used for research quality evaluation, with prior work exploring their scoring accuracy and the plausibility of review rationales. Howe…
cs.DL2026
Beyond Human-Likeness: Mapping the Scientific Critique Profiles of LLMs and Human Reviewers
Yunhan Yang, Mike Thelwall, Guoxiu He
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly discussed as tools for peer review, but their value is often assessed through human-likeness, perceived usefulness, or textual overlap…