Mathematical surprises and Dirac's formalism in quantum mechanics

Abstract

By a series of simple examples, we illustrate how the lack of mathematical concern can readily lead to surprising mathematical contradictions in wave mechanics. The basic mathematical notions allowing for a precise formulation of the theory are then summarized and it is shown how they lead to an elucidation and deeper understanding of the aforementioned problems. After stressing the equivalence between wave mechanics and the other formulations of quantum mechanics, i.e. matrix mechanics and Dirac's abstract Hilbert space formulation, we devote the second part of our paper to the latter approach: we discuss the problems and shortcomings of this formalism as well as those of the bra and ket notation introduced by Dirac in this context. In conclusion, we indicate how all of these problems can be solved or at least avoided.

Largely extended and reorganized version, with new title and abstract and with 2 figures added (published version), 54 pages

Cited by in corpus (31)

• Physics-inspired structural representations for molecules and materials
• Quantization Methods: A Guide for Physicists and Analysts
• Canonical Quantization and Impenetrable Barriers
• Spontaneous $\mathcal{T}$-symmetry breaking and exceptional points in cavity quantum electrodynamics systems
• Mathematical Methods of Theoretical Physics
• Classical and quantum dynamics of a particle constrained on a circle
• Bosonic field digitization for quantum computers
• On deformations of classical mechanics due to Planck-scale physics
• Covariant canonical formulations of classical field theories
• Observables in Quantum Mechanics and the Importance of Self-adjointness
• Canonical quantization on the half-line and in an interval based upon a new concept for the momentum in a space with boundaries
• Continuous-variable quantum state designs: theory and applications
• Coordinate representation for non Hermitian position and momentum operators
• Phase Spaces, Parity Operators, and the Born-Jordan Distribution
• Zwanziger's pairwise little group on the celestial sphere
• Bouncing Wave Packets, Ehrenfest Theorem, and Uncertainty Relation based upon a new Concept for the Momentum of a Particle in a Box
• Infrared signatures of quantum bounce in a minisuperspace analysis of Lema\^ıtre-Tolman-Bondi dust collapse
• Analyzing quantum gravity spillover in the semiclassical regime
• Broken Symmetry and Fractionalized Flux Strings in a Staggered U(1) Pure Gauge Theory
• Infinitesimal and Infinite Numbers as an Approach to Quantum Mechanics
• The Product Arbitrariness of Generalised Functions and its Role in Quantum Field Theory
• Dynamical symmetrization of the state of identical particles
• Passive quantum measurement: Arrival time, quantum Zeno effect and gambler's fallacy
• Quantization of nonlinear non-Hamiltonian systems
• Generalized uncertainty relations in spherical coordinates
• Constructibility of the universal wave function
• Do bras and kets have dimensions?
• On the representation-free formalism in quantum mechanics
• Co-Designing Spectral Transformation Oracles with Hybrid Oscillator-Qubit Quantum Processors: From Algorithms to Compilation
• On a paradox in quantum mechanics and its resolution
• All Hilbert spaces are the same: consequences for generalized coordinates and momenta