Critique of Protective Measurements
arXiv:quant-ph/9805012 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.59.2590
Abstract
Recently proposed idea of "protective" measurement of a quantum state is critically examined, and generalized. Earlier criticisms of the idea are discussed and their relevance to the proposal assessed. Several constraints on measuring apparatus required by "protective" measurements are discussed, with emphasis on how they may restrict their experimental feasibility. Though "protective" measurements result in an unchanged system state and a shift of the pointer proportional to the expectation value of the measured observable in the system state, the actual reading of the pointer position gives rise to several subtleties. We propose several schemes for reading pointer position, both when the apparatus is treated as a classical system as well as when its quantum aspects are taken into account, that address these issues. The tiny entanglement which is always present due to deviation from extreme adiabaticity in realistic situations is argued to be the weakest aspect of the proposal. Because of this, one can never perform a protective measurement on a single quantum system with absolute certainty. This clearly precludes an ontological status for the wave function. Several other conceptual issues are also discussed.
14 pages RevTex, published version with change in title
References in corpus (5)
Cited by in corpus (21)
- Determining the Quantum Expectation Value by Measuring a Single Photon
- The Meaning of the Wave Function: In Search of the Ontology of Quantum Mechanics
- Investigating the Effects of the Interaction Intensity in a Weak Measurement
- Meaning of the wave function
- Measuring the quantum state of a single system with minimum state disturbance
- Analysis of quantum-state disturbance in a protective measurement of a spin-1/2 particle
- Protective Measurement -- a new quantum measurement paradigm: detailed description of the first realisation
- State disturbance and pointer shift in protective quantum measurements
- The Wave Function and Quantum Reality
- Why protective measurement does not establish the reality of the quantum state
- An argument for psi-ontology in terms of protective measurements
- Protective Measurements and the Reality of the Wave Function
- Protective measurement of open quantum systems
- Protective measurements of photon polarization using a temporal pointer
- Performance advantage of protective quantum measurements
- Scheme for the protective measurement of a single photon using a tunable quantum Zeno effect
- Weak measurements and supraluminal communication
- Protective Measurements: Probing Single Quantum Systems
- Ontology and Quantum Mechanics
- Empirical State Determination of Entangled Two-Level Systems and its Relation to Information Theory
- Protective measurement of a qubit by a qubit probe