Dialogue Concerning Two Views on Quantum Coherence: Factist and Fictionist
arXiv:quant-ph/0507214 · doi:10.1142/S0219749906001591
Abstract
A controversy that has arisen many times over in disparate contexts is whether quantum coherences between eigenstates of certain quantities are fact or fiction. We present a pedagogical introduction to the debate in the form of a hypothetical dialogue between proponents from each of the two camps: a factist and a fictionist. A resolution of the debate can be achieved, we argue, by recognizing that quantum states do not only contain information about the intrinsic properties of a system but about its extrinsic properties as well, that is, about its relation to other systems external to it. Specifically, the coherent quantum state of the factist is the appropriate description of the relation of the system to one reference frame, while the incoherent quantum state of the fictionist is the appropriate description of the relation of the system to another, uncorrelated, reference frame. The two views, we conclude, are alternative but equally valid paradigms of description.
14 pages, Contribution to the Int. J. of Quant. Info. issue dedicated to the memory of Asher Peres; v2 updated summary and critique of prior literature
References in corpus (11)
- Classical and quantum communication without a shared reference frame
- Photon-number superselection and the entangled coherent-state representation
- Decoherence-full subsystems and the cryptographic power of a private shared reference frame
- Optimal measurements for relative quantum information
- Operational formulation of homodyne detection
- Quantifying the resource of sharing a reference frame
- Entanglement under restricted operations: Analogy to mixed-state entanglement
- Measurement Induced Localization of Relative Degrees of Freedom
- Continuous-Variable Quantum Teleportation with a Conventional Laser (Rev. Ver.)
- Continuous-Variable Quantum Teleportation with a Conventional Laser
- Defending Continuous Variable Teleportation: Why a laser is a clock, not a quantum channel
Cited by in corpus (48)
- Reference frames, superselection rules, and quantum information
- Catalytic Coherence
- The resource theory of quantum reference frames: manipulations and monotones
- Quantum phase estimation with lossy interferometers
- Quantum interferometry with and without an external phase reference
- Fundamental quantum interferometry bound for the squeezed-light-enhanced gravitational-wave detector GEO600
- Gibbs-Preserving Maps outperform Thermal Operations in the quantum regime
- On experimental procedures for entanglement verification
- Degradation of a quantum reference frame
- Quantum communication using a bounded-size quantum reference frame
- Physics within a quantum reference frame
- Quantum reference frames for general symmetry groups
- Symmetry, Reference Frames, and Relational Quantities in Quantum Mechanics
- Concepts of work in autonomous quantum heat engines
- Changing quantum reference frames
- The Geometry of Entanglement Sudden Death
- Dynamics of a Quantum Reference Frame
- Time-resolved Scattering of a Single Photon by a Single Atom
- Relativity of Quantum States and Observables
- How to observe a coherent superposition of an atom and a molecule
- Testing nonlocality of a single photon without a shared reference frame
- Localized qubits in curved spacetimes
- Probabilistic Cloning of Coherent States without a Phase Reference
- Optimal Universal Quantum Error Correction via Bounded Reference Frames
- Atomic entanglement generation and detection via degenerate four-wave-mixing of a Bose-Einstein condensate in an optical lattice
- Dialogue on analytical and ab initio methods in attoscience
- New Spin Squeezing and Other Entanglement Tests for Two Mode Systems of Identical Bosons
- Coherence cost for violating conservation laws
- Detecting mode entanglement: The role of coherent states, superselection rules and particle statistics
- Quantum Reference Frames and Their Applications to Thermodynamics
- Entanglement and Symmetry: A Case Study in Superselection Rules, Reference Frames, and Beyond
- Quantum reference frames for an indefinite metric
- Environment-induced quantum coherence spreading of a qubit
- Macroscopic Thermodynamic Reversibility in Quantum Many-Body Systems
- Absence of quantum optical coherence in high harmonic generation
- Measurement-Induced Collective Vibrational Quantum Coherence under Spontaneous Raman Scattering in a Liquid
- Transcoherent states: Optical states for maximal generation of atomic coherence
- Extreme spin squeezing for photons
- Describing squeezed-light experiments without squeezed-light states
- Superselection rules and bosonic quantum computational resources
- Quantum analysis of the direct measurement of light waves
- Symmetry-induced failures of tomographic locality: Constructing foil theories by twirling
- Searching for a physical description relative to a quantum system
- Testing Single Photon Entanglement using Self-Referential Measurements
- Quantum Resource Theory of Lasers
- Non-Gaussianity from superselection rules
- Describing two-mode squeezed-light experiments without two-mode entanglement or squeezing
- Quantum reference frames: derivation of perspective-dependent descriptions via a perspective-neutral structure