Comment on `Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies'
arXiv:quant-ph/0003036 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.87.069801
Abstract
In a recent paper, Eisert et al. presented a quantum mechanical generalization of Prisoner's Dilemma. They asserted that the maximally entangled game exhibits a unique Nash equilibrium which yields a pay-off equivalent to cooperative behaviour. In this comment we show that their observation is incorrect: there is no Nash equilibrium in the space of deterministic quantum strategies.
2 pages, 1 figure. Please address correspondence to [email protected]
References in corpus (1)
Cited by in corpus (61)
- Toward a general theory of quantum games
- Bell nonlocality and Bayesian game theory
- Quantum version of the Monty Hall problem
- Quantum games: a review of the history, current state, and interpretation
- Quantum Parrondo's Games
- Nash equilibria in quantum games with generalized two-parameter strategies
- Advantage of a quantum player over a classical one in 2x2 quantum games
- Entanglement Enhanced Multiplayer Quantum Games
- Backwards-induction outcome in a quantum game
- Classical and Quantum Contents of Solvable Game Theory on Hilbert Space
- A necessary and sufficient condition to play games in quantum mechanical settings
- Experimental implementation of a four-player quantum game
- Quantum Game Theory Based on the Schmidt Decomposition
- Duality, Phase Structures and Dilemmas in Symmetric Quantum Games
- Quantum two and three person duels
- Quantum Locality in Game Strategy
- Quantum Stackelberg duopoly in the presence of correlated noise
- Constructing quantum games from a system of Bell's inequalities
- Darwinism in quantum systems?
- Certified Quantum Computation in Isabelle/HOL
- Noisy Relativistic Quantum Games in Noninertial Frames
- Analyzing three-player quantum games in an EPR type setup
- Constructing quantum games from symmetric non-factorizable joint probabilities
- Quantum Key-Distribution Protocols Based on a Quantum Version of the Monty Hall Game
- Quantum Stackelberg duopoly in noninertial frame
- Analysis of two-player quantum games in an EPR setting using geometric algebra
- Playing games with EPR-type experiments
- Quantum version of a generalized Monty Hall game and its possible applications to quantum secure communications
- Hybrid cluster state proposal for a quantum game
- Nash Equilibrium in the Quantum Battle of Sexes Game
- Prisoners' Dilemma in Presence of Collective Dephasing
- General quantum two-players games, their gate operators and Nash equilibria
- Strong Quantum Solutions in Conflicting Interest Bayesian Games
- Simulation of continuous variable quantum games without entanglement
- Quantum entanglement, indistinguishability, and the absent-minded driver's problem
- Quantum correlations and Nash equilibria of a bi-matrix game
- Strong isomorphism in Eisert-Wilkens-Lewenstein type quantum games
- Three-players conflicting interest games and nonlocality
- Quantum-Optical set-up for the Monty Hall problem
- Quantum Penny Flip game with unawareness
- Two-player quantum games: When player strategies are via directional choices
- Multistage games and Bell scenarios with communication
- Comment on "Quantum Games and Quantum Strategies"
- Note on maximally entangled Eisert-Lewenstein-Wilkens quantum games
- Study of entanglement via a multi-agent dynamical quantum game
- Some properties of maximally entangled ELW game
- Quantum Entanglement transfer between spin-pairs
- Quantization of Blackjack: Quantum Basic Strategy and Advantage
- Quantum Strategic Game Theory
- Supersymmetry and quantum games
- Non-Cooperative Quantum Game Theory
- Entangling capabilities and unitary quantum games
- Quantum Cournot model based on general entanglement operator
- An introduction to multi-player, multi-choice quantum games
- On characterizing quantum correlated equilibria
- Investigations in quantum games using EPR-type set-ups
- Competition of different evaluation schemes in the continuous variable game
- Quantum strategy in moving frames
- On the equivalence between non-factorizable mixed-strategy classical games and quantum games
- Social optimality in quantum Bayesian games
- Quantum game players can have advantage without discord