An assessment of Evans' unified field theory I
arXiv:physics/0703116 · doi:10.1007/s10701-007-9190-0
Abstract
Evans developed a classical unified field theory of gravitation and electromagnetism on the background of a spacetime obeying a Riemann-Cartan geometry. This geometry can be characterized by an orthonormal coframe theta and a (metric compatible) Lorentz connection Gamma. These two potentials yield the field strengths torsion T and curvature R. Evans tried to infuse electromagnetic properties into this geometrical framework by putting the coframe theta to be proportional to four extended electromagnetic potentials A; these are assumed to encompass the conventional Maxwellian potential in a suitable limit. The viable Einstein-Cartan(-Sciama-Kibble) theory of gravity was adopted by Evans to describe the gravitational sector of his theory. Including also the results of an accompanying paper by Obukhov and the author, we show that Evans' ansatz for electromagnetism is untenable beyond repair both from a geometrical as well as from a physical point of view. As a consequence, his unified theory is obsolete.
arXiv comment39 pages of latex, modified because of referee report, mistakes and typos removed, partly reformulated, taken care of M.W.Evans' rebuttal
References in corpus (21)
- The Cosmological Parameters 2006
- Big-Bang nucleosynthesis (Particle Data Group mini-review)
- Metric-Affine Gauge Theory of Gravity: Field Equations, Noether Identities, World Spinors, and Breaking of Dilation Invariance
- Metric-Affine Gauge Theory of Gravity I. Fundamental Structure and Field Equations
- Exact vacuum solution of a (1+2)-dimensional Poincare gauge theory: BTZ solution with torsion
- Einstein-aether theory, violation of Lorentz invariance, and metric-affine gravity
- Gravitational Goldstone fields from affine gauge theory
- Invariant conserved currents in gravity theories with local Lorentz and diffeomorphism symmetry
- Einstein-Cartan theory as a theory of defects in space-time
- Lorentz invariance violation and charge (non--)conservation: A general theoretical frame for extensions of the Maxwell equations
- Energy-momentum current for coframe gravity
- Dimensions and Units in Electrodynamics
- On a class of invariant coframe operators with application to gravity
- Electric/magnetic reciprocity in premetric electrodynamics with and without magnetic charge, and the complex electromagnetic field
- An Ambiguous Statement Called 'Tetrad Postulate' and the Correct Field Equations Satisfied by the Tetrad Fields
- Energy-momentum conservation in pre-metric electrodynamics with magnetic charges
- Geometric Interpretation of Electromagnetism in a Gravitational Theory with Torsion and Spinorial Matter
- The Non Sequitur Mathematics and Physics of the 'New Electrodynamics' of the AIAS Group
- Vanishing Vierbein in Gauge Theories of Gravitation
- The Superposition Principle of Waves Not Fulfilled under M. W. Evans' O(3) Hypothesis
- The central error of M. W. Evans ECE theory - a type mismatch