Field transformations and simple models illustrating the impossibility of measuring off-shell effects

Abstract

In the context of simple models illustrating field transformations in Lagrangian field theories we discuss the impossibility of measuring off-shell effects in nucleon-nucleon bremsstrahlung, Compton scattering, and related processes. To that end we introduce a simple phenomenological Lagrangian describing nucleon-nucleon bremsstrahlung and perform an appropriate change of variables leading to different off-shell behavior in the nucleon-nucleon amplitude as well as the photon-nucleon vertex. As a result we obtain a class of equivalent Lagrangians, generating identical S-matrix elements, of which the original Lagrangian is but one representative. We make use of this property in order to show that what appears as an off-shell effect in an S-matrix element for one Lagrangian may originate in a contact term from an equivalent Lagrangian. By explicit calculation we demonstrate for the case of nucleon-nucleon bremsstrahlung as well as nucleon Compton scattering the equivalence of observables from which we conclude that off-shell effects cannot in any unambiguous way be extracted from an S-matrix element. Finally, we also discuss some implications of introducing off-shell effects on a phenomenological basis, resulting from the requirement that the description of one process be consistent with that of other processes described by the same Lagrangian.

19 pages, Latex, using RevTex

Cited by in corpus (34)

• Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces
• Relativistic chiral SU(3) symmetry, large N_c sum rules and meson-baryon scattering
• Meson production in nucleon--nucleon collisions close to the threshold
• Signatures of three-nucleon interactions in few-nucleon systems
• Hadrons in strongly interacting matter
• Induced pseudoscalar coupling of the proton weak interaction
• Measurement of the pi^+ meson polarizabilities via the gamma p->gamma pi^+ n reaction
• Self consistent propagation of hyperons and antikaons in nuclear matter based on relativistic chiral SU(3) dynamics
• Compton scattering on the nucleon at intermediate energies and polarizabilities in a microscopic model
• Field Redefinitions at Finite Density
• The $\rho$-meson light-cone distribution amplitudes from lattice QCD
• The nucleon as a test case to calculate vector-isovector form factors at low energies
• Deviation from the exponential decay law in relativistic quantum field theory: the example of strongly decaying particles
• Meson-exchange $\pi N$ Models in Three-Dimensional Bethe-Salpeter Formulation
• Using chiral perturbation theory to extract the neutron-neutron scattering length from pi- d -> n n gamma
• Improving the ultraviolet behavior in baryon chiral perturbation theory
• The physical meaning of scattering matrix singularities in coupled-channel formalisms
• Pion electroproduction, PCAC, chiral Ward identities, and the axial form factor revisited
• How to define physical properties of unstable particles
• Hadron structure and the limitations of phenomenological models in electromagnetic reactions
• $\eta$-${\eta }^{\prime }$ Mixing in Large-$N_c$ Chiral Perturbation Theory
• Offshell effects in electromagnetic reactions on the deuteron
• Selfconsistent approximations, symmetries and choice of representation
• Chiral behavior of vector meson self energies
• Subleading corrections to parity violating pion photoproduction
• Interaction current in $pp\to pp\gamma$
• The equivalence theorem and the Bethe-Salpeter equation
• In-medium meson properties and field transformations
• Renormalization of the Off-shell chiral two-pion exchange NN interactions
• The chiral Lagrangian with three flavors and large-Nc sum rules
• Gauge symmetric delta(1232) couplings and the radiative muon capture in hydrogen
• Electromagnetic currents for dressed hadrons
• ${\pi }_{e3}$ form factor $f_{-}$ near the mass shell
• Ratio of the proton electromagnetic form factors from meson dressing