Observability of the Bulk Casimir Effect: Can the Dynamical Casimir Effect be Relevant to Sonoluminescence?

Abstract

The experimental observation of intense light emission by acoustically driven, periodically collapsing bubbles of air in water (sonoluminescence) has yet to receive an adequate explanation. One of the most intriguing ideas is that the conversion of acoustic energy into photons occurs quantum mechanically, through a dynamical version of the Casimir effect. We have argued elsewhere that in the adiabatic approximation, which should be reliable here, Casimir or zero-point energies cannot possibly be large enough to be relevant. (About 10 MeV of energy is released per collapse.) However, there are sufficient subtleties involved that others have come to opposite conclusions. In particular, it has been suggested that bulk energy, that is, simply the naive sum of $\frac{1}{2}\hslash \omega$, which is proportional to the volume, could be relevant. We show that this cannot be the case, based on general principles as well as specific calculations. In the process we further illuminate some of the divergence difficulties that plague Casimir calculations, with an example relevant to the bag model of hadrons.

13 pages, REVTeX

References in corpus (3)

• Gauge Theories with Cayley-Klein $SO(2;j)$ and $SO(3;j)$ Gauge Groups
• Casimir effect in dielectrics: Bulk Energy Contribution
• Casimir effect in dielectrics: Surface area contribution

Cited by in corpus (41)

• New Developments in the Casimir Effect
• The Casimir effect: Recent controversies and progress
• On the ground state energy for a penetrable sphere and for a dielectric ball
• Identity of the van der Waals Force and the Casimir Effect and the Irrelevance of these Phenomena to Sonoluminescence
• Mode-by-mode summation for the zero point electromagnetic energy of an infinite cylinder
• Energy of the vacuum with a perfectly conducting and infinite cylindrical surface
• Casimir Energies and Pressures for $\delta$-function Potentials
• Direct mode summation for the Casimir energy of a solid ball
• Sonoluminescence as a QED vacuum effect. I: The Physical Scenario
• Casimir's energy of a conducting sphere and of a dilute dielectric ball
• Casimir Energies for Spherically Symmetric Cavities
• Casimir Energy for a Dielectric Cylinder
• The heat kernel coefficients for the dielectric cylinder
• Casimir Energy of a Ball and Cylinder in the Zeta Function Technique
• Casimir energy of a compact cylinder under the condition $\epsilon \mu =c^{-2}$
• Exact results for Casimir interactions between dielectric bodies: The weak-coupling or van der Waals Limit
• The Casimir Problem of Spherical Dielectrics: Quantum Statistical and Field Theoretical Approaches
• Casimir Surface Force on a Dilute Dielectric Ball
• Local and Global Casimir Energies for a Semitransparent Cylindrical Shell
• Sonoluminescence as a QED vacuum effect: Probing Schwinger's proposal
• Casimir energy and dilute dielectric ball
• Quantum radiation in external background fields
• Electromagnetic $\delta$-function sphere
• Dispersive forces on bodies and atoms: a unified approach
• Casimir effect for a dilute dielectric ball at finite temperature
• Self-Stress on a Dielectric Ball and Casimir-Polder Forces
• Energy conditions outside a dielectric ball
• Electromagnetic Vacuum of Complex Media: Dipole Emission vs. Light Propagation, Vacuum Energy, and Local Field Factors
• Casimir-Polder interactions with massive photons: implications for BSM physics
• Electromagnetic vacuum of complex media II: the Lamb shift and the total vacuum energy
• Casimir energy of a dilute dielectric ball at zero and finite temperature
• Gamma-Ray Burst Phenomenon as Collapse of QED Magnetized Vacuum Bubble: Analogy with Sonoluminescence
• Casimir Self-Entropy of Nanoparticles with Classical Polarizabilities: Electromagnetic Field Fluctuations
• Foundational Issues in Dynamical Casimir Effect and Analogue Features in Cosmological Particle Creation
• Casimir energy for a scalar field with a frequency dependent boundary condition
• Casimir Force between Vortex Matter in Anisotropic and Layered Superconductors
• Modelling Sonoluminescence
• Recent Developments in Quantum Vacuum Energy for Confined Fields
• Temperature effect in the Casimir attraction of a thin metal film
• On the possibility of the implicit renormalization procedure for the Casimir energy
• The covariant electromagnetic Casimir effect for real conducting spherical shells