Comment on "Surprises in threshold antikaon-nucleon physics"

Abstract

It has recently been claimed by Oller et al. [PRL 95 (2005) 172502] that the DEAR kaonic hydrogen data can be reconciled with K^- p scattering data in a chiral unitary approach. In this comment we demonstrate that the proposed solution violates fundamental principles of scattering theory.

1 page, 1 figure

References in corpus (2)

• Surprises in threshold antikaon-nucleon physics
• Kaonic hydrogen and K^- p scattering

Cited by in corpus (21)

• A New Measurement of Kaonic Hydrogen X rays
• Chiral SU(3) theory of antikaon-nucleon interactions with improved threshold constraints
• K^- p scattering length from scattering experiments
• The basic K nuclear cluster K- pp and its enhanced formation in the p + p -> K+ + X reaction
• $\bar{K}NN$ quasi-bound state and the $\bar{K}N$ interaction: coupled-channel Faddeev calculations of the $\bar{K}NN-\pi \Sigma N$ system
• Improved constraints on chiral SU(3) dynamics from kaonic hydrogen
• Kaonic hydrogen X-ray measurement in SIDDHARTA
• Meson-Baryon Effective Chiral Lagrangians to O(q^3)
• Review of the $\mathbf{\Lambda }$(1405): A curious case of a strange-ness resonance
• Non-perturbative methods for a chiral effective field theory of finite density nuclear systems
• QCD and the Strange Baryon Spectrum
• Coupled-channel approach in hadron-hadron scattering
• Structure of Lambda(1405) and construction of KbarN local potential based on chiral SU(3) dynamics
• Chiral SU(3) Dynamics and Antikaon-Nuclear quasibound States
• Baryonic resonances close to the Kbar-N threshold: the case of Sigma(1385)^+ in pp collisions
• Reply to Comment on "Surprises in threshold antikaon-nucleon physics"
• Prospects for e+e- physics at Frascati between the phi and the psi
• Recoil corrections in antikaon-deuteron scattering
• Measurement of the strong interaction induced shift and width of the 1s state of kaonic deuterium at J-PARC
• An in-medium chiral power counting for nuclear matter and some applications
• Baryon polarization in low-energy unpolarized meson-baryon scattering