Could the Pioneer anomaly have a gravitational origin?

Abstract

If the Pioneer anomaly has a gravitational origin, it would, according to the equivalence principle, distort the motions of the planets in the Solar System. Since no anomalous motion of the planets has been detected, it is generally believed that the Pioneer anomaly can not originate from a gravitational source in the Solar System. However, this conclusion becomes less obvious when considering models that either imply modifications to gravity at long range or gravitational sources localized to the outer Solar System, given the uncertainty in the orbital parameters of the outer planets. Following the general assumption that the Pioneer spacecraft move geodesically in a spherically symmetric spacetime metric, we derive the metric disturbance that is needed in order to account for the Pioneer anomaly. We then analyze the residual effects on the astronomical observables of the three outer planets that would arise from this metric disturbance, given an arbitrary metric theory of gravity. Providing a method for comparing the computed residuals with actual residuals, our results imply that the presence of a perturbation to the gravitational field necessary to induce the Pioneer anomaly is in conflict with available data for the planets Uranus and Pluto, but not for Neptune. We therefore conclude that the motion of the Pioneer spacecraft must be non-geodesic. Since our results are model independent within the class of metric theories of gravity, they can be applied to rule out any model of the Pioneer anomaly that implies that the Pioneer spacecraft move geodesically in a perturbed spacetime metric, regardless of the origin of this metric disturbance.

16 pages, 6 figures. Rev. 3: Major revision. Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. D. Rev. 4: Added two references

References in corpus (14)

• Relativistic gravitation theory for the MOND paradigm
• Study of the anomalous acceleration of Pioneer 10 and 11
• Indication, from Pioneer 10/11, Galileo, and Ulysses Data, of an Apparent Anomalous, Weak, Long-Range Acceleration
• The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
• What do the orbital motions of the outer planets of the Solar System tell us about the Pioneer anomaly?
• Conventional Forces can Explain the Anomalous Acceleration of Pioneer 10
• Testing the Newton law at long distances
• Gravity tests in the solar system and the Pioneer anomaly
• Post-Einsteinian tests of linearized gravitation
• The Pioneer anomaly in the context of the braneworld scenario
• Directly Measured Limit on the Interplanetary Matter Density from Pioneer 10 and 11
• Astrophysical Constraints on Scalar Field Models
• Analytic Gravitational-Force Calculations for Models of the Kuiper Belt, with Application to the Pioneer Anomaly
• The Pioneer Anomaly and Its Implications

Cited by in corpus (31)

• The Pioneer Anomaly
• On causality and superluminal behavior in classical field theories. Applications to k-essence theories and MOND-like theories of gravity
• Model for gravity at large distances
• Gravitational Anomalies in the Solar System?
• What do the orbital motions of the outer planets of the Solar System tell us about the Pioneer anomaly?
• Collider Signals of Gravitational Fixed Points
• Preliminary constraints on the location of the recently hypothesized new planet of the Solar System from planetary orbital dynamics
• Can the Pioneer anomaly be induced by velocity-dependent forces? Tests in the outer regions of solar system with planetary dynamics
• Nonlinear electrodynamics and the Pioneer 10/11 spacecraft anomaly
• How Well Do We Know the Orbits of the Outer Planets?
• Gravitation, electromagnetism and the cosmological constant in purely affine gravity
• Conformal Cosmology and the Pioneer Anomaly
• Effect of TTC on Satellite Orbital Mechanics
• Re-Examination of Globally Flat Space-Time
• Possible relation between galactic flat rotational curves and the Pioneers' anomalous acceleration
• On the effect of ocean tides and tesseral harmonics on spacecraft flybys of the Earth
• The Pioneer anomaly and the holographic scenario
• On a correlation among azimuthal velocities and the flyby anomaly sign
• Does the Neptunian system of satellites challenge a gravitational origin for the Pioneer anomaly?
• Constraining an Expanding Locally Anisotropic metric from the Pioneer anomaly
• Pioneer 10 and 11 Spacecraft Anomalous Acceleration in the light of the Nonsymmetric Kaluza-Klein (Jordan-Thiry) Theory
• On a recently proposed scalar-tensor-vector metric extension of general relativity to explain the Pioneer anomaly
• On the possible onset of the Pioneer anomaly
• Kinematics in Matrix Gravity
• A Model for the Pioneer Anomaly
• The dynamical nature of time
• On a recently proposed metric linear extension of general relativity to explain the Pioneer anomaly
• The LTP Experiment on LISA Pathfinder: Operational Definition of TT Gauge in Space
• A comment on the new non-conventional gravitational mechanism proposed by Jaekel and Reynaud to accommodate the Pioneer anomaly
• Non-Perturbative Aspects of Quantum Electrodynamics on Curved Space and Investigations in Matrix Gravity
• The Variable-c Cosmology as a Solution to Pioneer Anomaly