Simultaneity, radar 4-coordinates and the 3+1 point of view about accelerated observers in special relativity

Abstract

After a review of the 1+3 point of view on non-inertial observers and of the problems of rotating reference frames, we underline that was is lacking in their treatment is a good global notion of simultaneity due to the restricted validity of the existing 4-coordinates associated to an accelerated observer (like the Fermi normal ones). We show that the relativistic Hamiltonian 3+1 point of view, based on a 3+1 splitting of Minkowski space-time with a foliation whose space-like leaves are both simultaneity and Cauchy surfaces, allows to find a solution to such problems, if we take into account M$ø$ller's definition of allowed 4-coordinate transformations extended to radar 4-coordinates. Rigidly rotating relativistic reference frames are shown not to exist. We give explicit foliations, with simultaneity surfaces (also space-like hyper-planes) non orthogonal to the non-inertial observer world-line, which correspond to a good notion of simultaneity for suitable (mutually balancing) translational and rotational accelerations. This allows to evaluate the simultaneity-dependent one-way speed of light and to give the 3+1 description of both the rotating disk and the Sagnac effect. It is also shown how a GPS system of spacecrafts may establish a grid of admissible radar 4-coordinates and how the ACES mission can employ a variant of this method adapted to Earth's rotation in the evaluation of the one-way time transfer to detect the deviation from Einstein convention on the synchronization of inertial clocks implied by such a notion of simultaneity. We show that in parametrized Minkowski theories all the admissible notions of simultaneity are gauge equivalent ({\it conventionality of simultaneity}) and, as an example, we describe Maxwell theory in non-inertial systems with any admissible notion of simultaneity.

arXiv comment139 pages, RevTeX, final revised paper with a clarification of the interpretation of the time transfer in the ACES mission and new references

References in corpus (26)

• The IAU 2000 resolutions for astrometry, celestial mechanics and metrology in the relativistic framework: explanatory supplement
• Astrometry and geodesy with radio interferometry: experiments, models, results
• Absolute Frequency Measurements of the Hg^+ and Ca Optical Clock Transitions with a Femtosecond Laser
• Time Delay Interferometry with Moving Spacecraft Arrays
• A New Limit on Signals of Lorentz Violation in Electrodynamics
• Tests of relativity using a microwave resonator
• General Relativistic 1+3 Orthonormal Frame Approach Revisited
• Length measurement in accelerated systems
• N- and 1-time Classical Description of N-body Relativistic Kinematics and the Electromagnetic Interaction
• The Rest-Frame Instant Form of Metric Gravity
• Time transfer and frequency shift to the order 1/c^4 in the field of an axisymmetric rotating body
• General relativistic corrections to the Sagnac effect
• On the physical meaning of Fermi coordinates
• Real null coframes in general relativity and GPS type coordinates
• Navigation in Curved Space-Time
• Gravitomagnetism and Relative Observer Clock Effects
• The Rest-Frame Instant Form of Relativistic Perfect Fluids and of Non-Dissipative Elastic Materials
• Circular Holonomy, Clock Effects and Gravitoelectromagnetism: Still Going Around in Circles After All These Years
• General Covariance and the Objectivity of Space-Time Point-Events: The Physical Role of Gravitational and Gauge Degrees of Freedom in General Relativity
• Universal one-way light speed from a universal light speed over closed paths
• Electromagnetic Forces and Fields in a Rotating Reference Frame
• Fermi Coordinates of an Observer Moving in a Circle in Minkowski Space: Apparent Behavior of Clocks
• Geometry of rotating disk and the Sagnac effect
• Simultaneity and the Concept of `Particle'
• Time Delay Interferometry and LISA Optimal Sensitivity
• Uniqueness of Simultaneity

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Charged Particles and the Electro-Magnetic Field in Non-Inertial Frames of Minkowski Spacetime: I. Admissible 3+1 Splittings of Minkowski Spacetime and the Non-Inertial Rest Frames
• The Chrono-geometrical Structure of Special and General Relativity: a Re-Visitation of Canonical Geometrodynamics
• Charged Particles and the Electro-Magnetic Field in Non-Inertial Frames of Minkowski Spacetime: II. Applications: Rotating Frames, Sagnac Effect, Faraday Rotation, Wrap-up Effect
• Towards Relativistic Atomic Physics. I. The Rest-Frame Instant Form of Dynamics and a Canonical Transformation for a System of Charged Particles plus the Electro-Magnetic Field
• Static Observers in Curved Spaces and Non-inertial Frames in Minkowski Spacetime
• A globally well-behaved simultaneity connection for stationary frames in the weak field limit
• The Chrono'Geometrical Structure of Special and General Relativity: Towards a Background-Independent Description of the Gravitational Field and Elementary Particles
• Locality hypothesis and the speed of light
• Canonical Reduction of Gravity: from General Covariance to Dirac Observables and post-Minkowskian Background-Independent Gravitational Waves
• The York Map and the Role of Non-Inertial Frames in the Geometrical View of the Gravitational Field
• Relativistic Atomic Physics: from Atomic Clock Synchronization towards Relativistic Entanglement
• Explaining Leibniz-equivalence as difference of non-inertial appearances: dis-solution of the Hole Argument and physical individuation of point-events