Are citations of scientific papers a case of nonextensivity ?

Abstract

The distribution $N(x)$ of citations of scientific papers has recently been illustrated (on ISI and PRE data sets) and analyzed by Redner [Eur. Phys. J. B {\bf 4}, 131 (1998)]. To fit the data, a stretched exponential ($N(x)\propto \exp -(x/x_0{)}^{\beta }$) has been used with only partial success. The success is not complete because the data exhibit, for large citation count $x$, a power law (roughly $N(x)\propto x^{-3}$ for the ISI data), which, clearly, the stretched exponential does not reproduce. This fact is then attributed to a possibly different nature of rarely cited and largely cited papers. We show here that, within a nonextensive thermostatistical formalism, the same data can be quite satisfactorily fitted with a single curve (namely, $N(x)\propto 1/[1+(q-1)\lambda x{]}^{q/q-1}$ for the available values of $x$. This is consistent with the connection recently established by Denisov [Phys. Lett. A {\bf 235}, 447 (1997)] between this nonextensive formalism and the Zipf-Mandelbrot law. What the present analysis ultimately suggests is that, in contrast to Redner's conclusion, the phenomenon might essentially be one and the same along the entire range of the citation number $x$.

Revtex,1 Figure postscript;[email protected]

Cited by in corpus (36)

• Power-law distributions in empirical data
• Evolution of networks
• Structure of Growing Networks: Exact Solution of the Barabasi--Albert's Model
• Analyzing and Modeling Real-World Phenomena with Complex Networks: A Survey of Applications
• An index to quantify an individual's scientific research valid across disciplines
• Scaling Behaviour of Developing and Decaying Networks
• Characterizing and modeling citation dynamics
• Citation Networks in High Energy Physics
• q-exponential, Weibull, and q-Weibull distributions: an empirical analysis
• q-Exponential Distribution in Urban Agglomeration
• Thesaurus as a complex network
• Continuous growth models in terms of generalized logarithm and exponential functions
• Itineration of the Internet over Nonequilibrium Stationary States in Tsallis Statistics
• Regularities in football goal distributions
• Runaway Events Dominate the Heavy Tail of Citation Distributions
• Empirical nonextensive laws for the county distribution of total personal income and gross domestic product
• Generalized exponential function and discrete growth models
• Mixing and equilibration: Protagonists in the scene of nonextensive statistical mechanics
• Renormalization group approach to nonextensive statistical mechanics
• What is the dimension of citation space?
• Scale-free download network for publications
• Parallel Generation of Massive Scale-Free Graphs
• Fluctuation of the download network
• Dynamical Stationarity as a Result of Sustained Random Growth
• Zipf-Mandelbrot-Pareto model for co-authorship popularity
• Towards a more realistic citation model: The key role of research team sizes
• Size limiting in Tsallis statistics
• Modeling statistics of the natural aggregation structures and processes with the solution of generalized logistic equation
• Universality in Bibliometrics
• A classification of natural and social distributions Part one: the descriptions
• We cite as we communicate: A communication model for the citation process
• Equilibrium distributions in entropy driven balanced processes
• Generalized Exponential Function and some of its Applications to Complex Systems
• Power law dynamics in genealogical graphs
• Modeling a Century of Citation Distributions
• A New Benchmark For Evaluation Of Graph-Theoretic Algorithms