Comment on "Tricritical Behavior in Rupture Induced by Disorder"

Abstract

In their letter, Andersen, Sornette, and Leung [Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 2140 (1997)] describe possible behaviors for rupture in disordered media, based on the mean field-like democratic fiber bundle model. In this model, fibers are pulled with a force which is distributed uniformly. A fiber breaks if the stress on it exceeds a threshold chosen from a probability distribution, and the force is then redistributed over the intact fibers. Andersen et al. claim the existence of a tricritical point, separating a "first-order" regime, characterized by a sudden global failure, from a "second-order" regime, characterized by a divergence in the breaking rate. We show that a first-order transition is an artifact of a (large enough) discontinuity put by hand in the disorder distribution. Thus, in generic physical cases, a first-order regime is not present. This result is obtained from a graphical method, which, unlike Andersen at al.'s analytical solution, enables us to distinguish the various classes of qualitatively different behaviors of the model.

1 page, 1 figure included, revtex

Cited by in corpus (16)

• Statistical Models of Fracture
• Failure Processes in Elastic Fiber Bundles
• Universality Class of Fiber Bundle Model on Complex Networks
• Phase transition in fiber bundle models with recursive dynamics
• Robustness of power systems under a democratic fiber bundle-like model
• Optimizing the robustness of electrical power systems against cascading failures
• Modes of failures in disordered solids
• Cascades in interdependent flow networks
• An Introduction to Breakdown Phenomena in Disordered Systems
• The Random Fuse Network as a Dipolar Magnet
• The equal load-sharing model of cascade failures in power grids
• Failure regime in (1+1) dimensions in fibrous materials
• Phase Transitions in Load Transfer Models of Fracture
• Applicability and non-applicability of equilibrium statistical mechanics to non-thermal damage phenomena: II. Spinodal behavior
• Conditions for abrupt failure in the democratic fiber bundle model
• Failure process of fiber bundles with random misalignment