Scaling of the linear response function from zero field cooled and thermoremanent magnetization in phase ordering kinetics

Abstract

In this paper we investigate the relation between the scaling properties of the linear response function $R(t,s)$, of the thermoremanent magnetization (TRM) and of the zero field cooled magnetization (ZFC) in the context of phase ordering kinetics. We explain why the retrival of the scaling properties of $R(t,s)$ from those of TRM and ZFC is not trivial. Preasymptotic contributions generate a long crossover in TRM, while ZFC is affected by a dangerous irrelevant variable. Lack of understanding of both these points has generated some confusion in the literature. The full picture relating the exponents of all the quantities involved is explicitely illustrated in the framework of the large $N$ model. Following this scheme, an assessment of the present status of numerical simulations for the Ising model can be made. We reach the conclusion that on the basis of the data available up to now, statements on the scaling properties of $R(t,s)$ can be made from ZFC but not from TRM. From ZFC data for the Ising model with $d=2,3,4$ we confirm the previously found linear dependence on dimensionality of the exponent $a$ entering $R(t,s)\sim s^{-(1+a)}f(t/s)$. We also find evidence that a recently derived form of the scaling function $f(x)$, using local scale invariance arguments [M.Henkel, M.Pleimling, C.Godrèche and J.M.Luck, Phys.Rev.Lett. {\bf 87}, 265701 (2001)], does not hold for the Ising model.

26 pages, 14 figures

References in corpus (7)

• Violation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem in glassy systems: basic notions and the numerical evidence
• Two-loop Critical Fluctuation-Dissipation Ratio for the Relaxational Dynamics of the O(N) Landau-Ginzburg Hamiltonian
• Scaling of the magnetic linear response in phase-ordering kinetics
• Aging at Criticality in Model C Dynamics
• Relaxation and overlap probability function in the spherical and mean spherical model
• Comment on "Aging, phase ordering and conformal invariance"
• Reply to a Comment

Cited by in corpus (41)

• Ageing Properties of Critical Systems
• Off-equilibrium generalization of the fluctuation dissipation theorem for Ising spins and measurement of the linear response function
• Nonlinear response and fluctuation dissipation relations
• Crossover in Growth Law and Violation of Superuniversality in the Random Field Ising Model
• Ageing in disordered magnets and local scale-invariance
• Fluctuation-Dissipation relations far from Equilibrium
• Scaling of the linear response in simple ageing systems without disorder
• Growth Law and Superuniversality in the Coarsening of Disordered Ferromagnets
• Scaling Behavior of Response Functions in the Coarsening Dynamics of Disordered Ferromagnets
• Fluctuations in the coarsening dynamics of the O(N) model: are they similar to those in glassy systems?
• Fluctuation-dissipation relations and field-free algorithms for the computation of response functions
• Influence of thermal fluctuations on the geometry of the interfaces of the quenched Ising model
• Scaling and universality in the aging kinetics of the two-dimensional clock model
• Effective temperature in the quench of coarsening systems to and below $T_C$
• Phase-ordering kinetics on graphs
• Coarsening in inhomogeneous systems
• Spin, bond and global fluctuation-dissipation relations in the non-equilibrium spherical ferromagnet
• Generic features of the fluctuation dissipation relation in coarsening systems
• Scaling in the Aging Dynamics of the Site-diluted Ising Model
• Correction to scaling in the response function of the 2d kinetic Ising model
• Test of Local Scale Invariance from the direct measurement of the response function in the Ising model quenched to and to below $T_C$
• Aging dynamics and the topology of inhomogenous networks
• Domain growth and aging scaling in coarsening disordered systems
• The fluctuation-dissipation relation in an Ising model without detailed balance
• The role of initial state and final quench temperature on the aging properties in phase-ordering kinetics
• Fluctuations and effective temperatures in coarsening
• Physical ageing from generalised time-translation-invariance
• Comment on "Scaling of the linear response in simple aging systems without disorder"
• Phase ordering in disordered and inhomogeneous systems
• Topological regulation of activation barriers on fractal substrates
• The non-equilibrium response of the critical Ising model: Universal scaling properties and Local Scale Invariance
• Phase ordering and universality for continuous symmetry models on graphs
• Reply to "Comment on 'Scaling of the linear response in simple ageing systems without disorder' "
• Fluctuations of two-time quantities and non-linear response functions
• Observable Dependent Quasi-Equilibrium in Slow Dynamics
• Non-equilibrium critical properties of the Ising model on product graphs
• Growth Kinetics and Aging Phenomena in a Frustrated System
• Non trivial behavior of the linear response function in phase ordering kinetics
• On a relation between roughening and coarsening
• Effects of Frustration on Fluctuation-dissipation Relations
• On the predictive power of Local Scale Invariance