Modeling Rumors: The No Plane Pentagon French Hoax Case
arXiv:cond-mat/0211571 · doi:10.1016/S0378-4371(02)01582-0
Abstract
The recent astonishing wide adhesion of french people to the rumor claiming `No plane did crash on the Pentagon on September the 11", is given a generic explanation in terms of a model of minority opinion spreading. Using a majority rule reaction-diffusion dynamics, a rumor is shown to invade for sure a social group provided it fulfills simultaneously two criteria. First it must initiate with a support beyond some critical threshold which however, turns out to be always very low. Then it has to be consistent with some larger collective social paradigm of the group. Othewise it just dies out. Both conditions were satisfied in the french case with the associated book sold at more than 200 000 copies in just a few days. The rumor was stopped by the firm stand of most newspaper editors stating it is nonsense. Such an incredible social dynamics is shown to result naturally from an open and free public debate among friends and colleagues. Each one searching for the truth sincerely on a free will basis and without individual biases. The polarization process appears also to be very quick in agreement with reality. It is a very strong anti-democratic reversal of opinion although made quite democratically. The model may apply to a large range of rumors.
References in corpus (4)
Cited by in corpus (33)
- Theory of Rumour Spreading in Complex Social Networks
- Sociophysics: A review of Galam models
- Hoaxy: A Platform for Tracking Online Misinformation
- Contrarian Deterministic Effect: the "Hung Elections Scenario"
- Heterogeneous believes, segregation and extremism in the making of public opinions
- Affinity Paths and Information Diffusion in Social Networks
- Neighborhood models of minority opinion spreading
- Emergence of influential spreaders in modified rumor models
- Chaotic, staggered and polarized dynamics in opinion forming: the contrarian effect
- Social Structure and Opinion Formation
- Network segregation in a model of misinformation and fact checking
- Global Physics: From Percolation to Terrorism, Guerilla Warfare and Clandestine Activities
- Anti-rumor dynamics and emergence of the timing threshold on complex network
- From Public Outrage to the Burst of Public Violence: An Epidemic-Like Model
- The dynamics of opinion in hierarchical organizations
- From subcritical behavior to elusive transitions in rumor models
- Inefficiency of voting in Parrondo games
- Discrete Opinion models as a limit case of the CODA model
- Fake news and rumors: a trigger for proliferation or fading away
- The Galam Model of Minority Opinion Spreading and the Marriage Gap
- Controversy-seeking fuels rumor-telling activity in polarized opinion networks
- Effects of inhomogeneous influence of individuals on an order-disorder transition in opinion dynamics
- A Spatially Extended Model for Residential Segregation
- Containing rumors spreading on correlated multiplex networks
- Interdependent binary choices under social influence: phase diagram for homogeneous unbiased populations
- A Bayesian Framework for Opinion Updates
- Sociophysics and the Forming of Public Opinion: Threshold versus Non Threshold Dynamics
- Conspiratorial beliefs observed through entropy principles
- Combined update scheme in the Sznajd model
- Internet comments as a barometer of public opinion
- A case study of conspiracy theories about Charlie Hebdo terrorist attack
- Global Warming: the Sacrificial Temptation
- The SIS Competition Model for Conflicting Rumors