Evidence Against an Association Between Gamma-Ray Bursts and Type I Supernovae

Abstract

We present a rigorous method, based on Bayesian inference, for calculating the odds favoring the hypothesis that any particular class of astronomical transients produce gamma-ray bursts over the hypothesis that they do not. We then apply this method to a sample of 83 Type Ia supernovae and a sample of 20 Type Ib-Ic supernovae. We find overwhelming odds against the hypothesis that all Type Ia supernovae produce gamma-ray bursts, whether at low redshift ($10^9:1$) or high-redshift ($10^{12}:1$), and very large odds ($6000:1$) against the hypothesis that all Type Ib, Ib/c, and Ic supernovae produce observable gamma-ray bursts. We find large odds ($34:1$) against the hypothesis that a fraction of Type Ia supernovae produce observable gamma-ray bursts, and moderate odds ($6:1$) against the hypothesis that a fraction of Type Ib-Ic supernovae produce observable bursts. We have also re-analyzed both a corrected version of the Wang & Wheeler sample of Type Ib-Ic SNe and our larger sample of 20 Type Ib-Ic SNe, using a generalization of their frequentist method. We find no significant evidence in either case of a correlation between Type Ib-Ic SNe and GRBs, consistent with the very strong evidence against such a correlation that we find from our Bayesian analysis.

45 pages, 2 PostScript figures. Uses AASTEX macros. Submitted to The Astrophysical Journal

Cited by in corpus (7)

• A Possible Cepheid-Like Luminosity Estimator for the Long Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Study of Gamma Ray Burst Binary Progenitors
• HST/STIS Imaging of the Host Galaxy of GRB980425/SN1998bw
• Can Gamma Ray Bursts Produce the Observed Cosmic Rays Above $10^{20}$ eV?
• Probabilistic record linkage in astronomy: Directional cross-identification and beyond
• Effects of Luminosity Functions Induced by Relativistic Beaming on Statistics of Cosmological Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Radio Emission from Supernovae