Correlated errors in Hipparcos parallaxes towards the Pleiades and the Hyades

Abstract

We show that the errors in the Hipparcos parallaxes towards the Pleiades and the Hyades open clusters are spatially correlated over angular scales of 2 to 3 deg, with an amplitude of up to 2 mas. This correlation is stronger than expected based on the analysis of the Hipparcos catalog. We predict the parallaxes of individual cluster members, pi_pm, from their Hipparcos proper motions, assuming that all cluster members have the same space velocity. We compare pi_pm with their Hipparcos parallaxes, pi_Hip, and find that there are significant spatial correlations in pi_Hip. We derive a distance modulus to the Pleiades of 5.58 +- 0.18 mag using the radial-velocity gradient method. This value, agrees very well with the distance modulus of 5.60 +- 0.04 mag determined using the main-sequence fitting technique, compared with the value of 5.33 +- 0.06 inferred from the average of the Hipparcos parallaxes of the Pleiades members. We show that the difference between the main-sequence fitting distance and the Hipparcos parallax distance can arise from spatially correlated errors in the Hipparcos parallaxes of individual Pleiades members. Although the Hipparcos parallax errors towards the Hyades are spatially correlated in a manner similar to those of the Pleiades, the center of the Hyades is located on a node of this spatial structure. Therefore, the parallax errors cancel out when the average distance is estimated, leading to a mean Hyades distance modulus that agrees with the pre-Hipparcos value. We speculate that these spatial correlations are also responsible for the discrepant distances that are inferred using the mean Hipparcos parallaxes to some open clusters. Finally, we note that our conclusions are based on a purely geometric method and do not rely on any models of stellar isochrones.

33 pages including 10 Figures, revised version accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (3)

• The Problem of Hipparcos Distances to Open Clusters: I. Constraints from Multicolor Main Sequence Fitting
• The Problem of Hipparcos Distances to Open Clusters. II. Constraints from Nearby Field Stars
• A Precision test of Hipparcos systematics towards the Hyades

Cited by in corpus (38)

• Validation of the new Hipparcos reduction
• Parallaxes and proper motions for 20 open clusters as based on the new Hipparcos catalogue
• Distances, ages, and epoch of formation of globular clusters
• A Hipparcos study of the Hyades open cluster: Improved colour-absolute magnitude and Hertzsprung-Russell diagrams
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. III. Improved Accuracy with Empirically Calibrated Isochrones
• Eclipsing binaries as standard candles: HD 23642 and the distance to the Pleiades
• Astrometry with Hubble Space Telescope: A Parallax of the Fundamental Distance Calibrator RR Lyrae
• Confirmation of Errors in Hipparcos Parallaxes from HST/FGS Astrometry of the Pleiades
• New Period-Luminosity and Period-Color Relations of Classical Cepheids: II. Cepheids in LMC
• A VLBI Resolution of the Pleiades Distance Controversy
• Astrometric radial velocities III. Hipparcos measurements of nearby star clusters and associations
• Why are the K dwarfs in the Pleiades so Blue?
• The Metallicity of the Pleiades
• New period-luminosity and period-color relations of classical Cepheids: III. Cepheids in SMC
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. I. New Models and a Comparison to the Properties of the Hyades Eclipsing Binary vB 22
• The distance to the Pleiades from orbital solution of the double-lined eclipsing binary HD 23642
• A new reduction of the raw Hipparcos data
• Rotation and activity in the solar-metallicity open cluster NGC2516
• The problem of the Pleiades distance. Constraints from Stromgren photometry of nearby field stars
• Stellar Structure and Evolution: Deductions from Hipparcos
• A Gaia study of the Hyades open cluster
• First VLTI/MIDI observations of a Be star: Alpha Ara
• Hipparcos open clusters and stellar evolution
• Rights and wrongs of the Hipparcos data: A critical assessment of the Hipparcos catalogue
• Astrometry with the Hubble Space Telescope: Trigonometric Parallaxes of Selected Hyads
• The IMF of open star clusters with Tycho-2
• Orbital elements, masses and distance of lambda Scorpii A and B determined with the Sydney University Stellar Interferometer and high resolution spectroscopy
• A revised moving cluster distance to the Pleiades open cluster
• Comparison of Gaia and Hipparcos parallaxes of close visual binary stars and the impact on determinations of their masses
• Hyades dynamics from N-body simulations: Accuracy of astrometric radial velocities from Hipparcos
• Two Boehm-Vitense gaps in the main sequence of the Hyades
• Spectroscopic Survey of G and K Dwarfs in the Hipparcos Catalog. I. Comparison between the Hipparcos and Photometric Parallaxes
• An updated maximum likelihood approach to open cluster distance determination
• The Structure and the Distance of Collinder 121 from Hipparcos and Photometry: Resolving the Discrepancy
• A New Kinematic Distance Estimator to the LMC
• Pseudomagnitude Distances: Application to the Pleiades cluster
• Toward a VLBI resolution of the Pleiades distance controversy
• The Hipparcos Pleiades parallax error is also a proper motion error