Cosmological Implications of Two Conflicting Deuterium Abundances

Abstract

Constraints on big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) and on cosmological parameters from conflicting deuterium observations in different high red-shift QSO systems are discussed. The high deuterium observations by Carswell et al., Songaila et al., and Rugers & Hogan is consistent with 4He and 7Li observations and Standard BBN (N_nu =3) and allows N_nu \leq 3.6 at 95% C.L., but is inconsistent with local observations of D and 3He in the context of conventional theories of stellar and Galactic evolution. In contrast, the low deuterium observations by Tytler, Fan & Burles and Burles & Tytler are consistent with the constraints from local Galactic observations, but require N_nu = 1.9 +/- 0.3 at 68% C.L., excluding Standard BBN at 99.9% C.L., unless the systematic uncertainties in the 4He observations have been underestimated by a large amount. The high and low primordial deuterium abundances imply, respectively, Omega_B h^2 = 0.005 - 0.01 and Omega_B h^2 = 0.02 - 0.03 at 95% C.L. When combined with the high baryon fraction inferred from x-ray observations of rich clusters, the corresponding total mass densities (for 50 \le H_0 \le 90) are Omega_M = 0.05 - 0.20 and Omega_M = 0.2 - 0.7, respectively (95\% C.L.) The range of Omega_M corresponding to high D is in conflict with dynamical constraints (Omega_M > 0.2 - 0.3) and with the shape parameter constraint (Gamma = Omega_M h = 0.25 +/- 0.05) from large scale structure formation in CDM and Lambda-CDM models.

29p including 12 postscript figures, uses REVTEX 3.0 and epsf.sty, entire ps file with embedded figures available at ftp://upenn5.hep.upenn.edu/pub/hata/papers/Dqso.ps.gz

References in corpus (16)

• Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis and the Baryon Density of the Universe
• Einstein Observatory evidence for the widespread baryon overdensity in clusters of galaxies,
• On the Abundance of Primordial Helium
• Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in Crisis?
• Action Principle Solutions For Galaxy Motions Within 3000 Km/s
• Galactic Evolution Of D And 3He Including Stellar Production Of 3He
• Do Galactic Systems Form Too Late in Cold+Hot Dark Matter Models?
• A Wavelet Space-Scale-Decomposition Analysis of Structure and Evolution fo QSO's Ly$\alpha$ Absorption Lines
• Generic Evolution Of Deuterium And Helium-3
• Predicting Big Bang Deuterium
• Search for Intra-Cluster Machos by Pixel Lensing of M87
• Cosmic Deuterium Or A Hydrogen Interloper ?
• Dark Matter and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
• Relaxing the Big-bang Bound to the Baryon Density
• THE X-RAY CLUSTER BARYON CRISIS
• Nucleosynthesis and the mass of the tau neutrino

Cited by in corpus (44)

• Neutrinos in cosmology
• The Deuterium Abundance Towards Q1937-1009
• The Opacity of the Lyman Alpha Forest and Implications for Omega_{baryon} and the Ionizing Background
• The Deuterium Abundance Towards Q1009+2956
• Primordial Nucleosynthesis in Light of WMAP
• A Matter-Antimatter Universe?
• The Primordial Abundance of He4: An Update
• Neutrino Decay as an Explanation of Atmospheric Neutrino Observations
• A High Deuterium Abundance at z=0.7
• Halo Star Lithium Depletion
• Third Generation Familons, B Factories, and Neutrino Cosmology
• Big bang nucleosynthesis limit on N_nu
• Solar Neutrino Constraints on the BBN Production of Li
• Quantifying uncertainties in primordial nucleosynthesis without Monte Carlo simulations
• A Mechanism for Ordinary-Sterile Neutrino Mixing
• Primordial Nucleosynthesis with CMB Inputs: Probing the Early Universe and Light Element Astrophysics
• How neutrino oscillations can induce an effective neutrino number of less than 3 during Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
• Cosmological Nucleosynthesis and Active-Sterile Neutrino Oscillations with Small Mass Differences: The Nonresonant Case
• Four-Neutrino Mixing and Big-Bang Nucleosynthesis
• Relic neutrino asymmetries and big bang nucleosynthesis in a four neutrino model
• Neutrino Mass-An Overview
• Cosmological nucleosynthesis and active-sterile neutrino oscillations with small mass differences: The resonant case
• Generalized Limits to the Number of Light Particle Degrees of Freedom from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
• Implications of the ${\nu }_{\mu }\to {\nu }_s$ solution to the atmospheric neutrino anomaly for early Universe cosmology
• Three Neutrino $\Delta m^2$ scales and Singular Seesaw Mechanism
• Description of nuclear systems within the relativistic Hartree-Fock method with zero range self-interactions of the scalar field
• Active-Sterile neutrino oscillations and BBN+CMBR constraints
• Light Unstable Sterile Neutrino
• Hierarchical Four-Neutrino Oscillations With a Decay Option
• Pseudo-Dirac neutrinos as a potential complete solution to the neutrino oscillation puzzle
• Is Deuterium in High Redshift Lyman Limit Systems Primordial?
• Soft Dipole Modes in Neutron-rich Ni-isotopes in QRRPA
• Non-Nucleosynthetic Constraints on the Baryon Density and Other Cosmological Parameters
• Relativistic mean field study of the newly discovered $\alpha$-decay chain of ${}^{287}$115
• Neutrino Production of Deuterium in Supermassive Stars and Possible Implications for Deuterium Detections in Ly-Limit Systems
• Baryonic Mass Fraction in Rich Clusters and the Total Mass Density in the Cosmos
• Neutron Diffusion and Nucleosynthesis in an Inhomogeneous Big Bang Model
• Neutron halo in deformed nuclei from a relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov model in a Woods-Saxon basis
• Multi-dimensional potential energy surfaces and non-axial octupole correlations in actinide and transfermium nuclei from relativistic mean field models
• Isovector Giant Dipole Resonance of Stable Nuclei in a Consistent Relativistic Random Phase Approximation
• An effective Nuclear Model: from Nuclear Matter to Finite Nuclei
• Properties of superdeformed fission isomers in the cranked relativistic Hartree-Bogoliubov theory
• H-dibaryons and Primordial Nucleosynthesis
• Limits on Majorana Neutrinos from Recent Experimental Data