Testing the Gravitational Instability Hypothesis?

Abstract

We challenge a widely accepted assumption of observational cosmology: that successful reconstruction of observed galaxy density fields from measured galaxy velocity fields (or vice versa), using the methods of gravitational instability theory, implies that the observed large-scale structures and large-scale flows were produced by the action of gravity. This assumption is false, in that there exist non-gravitational theories that pass the reconstruction tests and gravitational theories with certain forms of biased galaxy formation that fail them. Gravitational instability theory predicts specific correlations between large-scale velocity and mass density fields, but the same correlations arise in any model where (a) structures in the galaxy distribution grow from homogeneous initial conditions in a way that satisfies the continuity equation, and (b) the present-day velocity field is irrotational and proportional to the time-averaged velocity field. We demonstrate these assertions using analytical arguments and N-body simulations of gravitational and non-gravitational models. We also show examples of gravitational and non-gravitational models that {\it fail} reconstruction tests because galaxy formation is modulated (``biased'') in a way that violates the continuity equation. We discuss the relation between the value of $\Omega$ inferred from velocity-density comparisons and the true cosmological value.

plain tex, 34 pp; postscript version w/ 17 figures available by anonymous ftp; to appear in ApJ; IAS preprint #93-67

Cited by in corpus (31)

• The density and peculiar velocity fields of nearby galaxies
• Dwarf Galaxy Rotation Curves and the Core Problem of Dark Matter Halos
• The structure of voids
• Secular bar formation in galaxies with significant amount of dark matter
• The Shape of the Gravitational Potential in Cold Dark Matter Halos
• The Origin of the Density Distribution of Disk Galaxies: A New Problem for the Standard Model of Disk Formation
• The Angular Momentum Content of Dwarf Galaxies: New Challenges for the Theory of Galaxy Formation
• Dark matter distribution in dwarf spheroidal galaxies
• The Inner Structure of LCDM Halos II: Halo Mass Profiles and LSB Rotation Curves
• A Non Parametric Model for the Cosmic Velocity Field
• The constant density region of the dark halos of spiral galaxies
• POTENT Reconstruction from Mark III Velocities
• The Fundamental Plane of Ellipticals: I. The Dark Matter Connection
• Constraints on dark matter and the shape of the Milky Way dark halo from the 511 keV line
• Disc galaxy evolution models in a hierarchical formation scenario: structure and dynamics
• The Phase-Space Parameters of Brightest Halo Galaxies
• Hiding Cusps in Cores: Kinematics of Disk Galaxies in Triaxial Dark Matter Halos
• On DDO154 and Cold Dark Matter halo profiles
• H-alpha Kinematics of the SINGS Nearby Galaxies Survey. II
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics of Large Scale Structure
• Locally Biased Galaxy Formation and Large Scale Structure
• The Cusp/Core problem: supernovae feedback versus the baryonic clumps and dynamical friction model
• The joint evolution of baryons and dark matter haloes
• Collisional baryonic dark matter halos
• Biased Galaxy Formation And Measurements Of Beta
• Spatial and Dynamical Biases in Velocity Statistics of Galaxies
• Completely dark galaxies: their existence, properties, and strategies for finding them
• Dynamical flows through Dark Matter Haloes II: one and two points statistics at the virial radius
• The Halo Density Profiles with Non-Standard N-body Simulations
• Nucleosynthesis in a Simmering Universe
• The Peculiar-Velocity-Field in Structure Formation Theories with Cosmic Strings