On the weakness of disc models in bright ULXs
arXiv:astro-ph/0606273 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2006.10687.x
Abstract
It is sometimes suggested that phenomenological power-law plus cool disc-blackbody models represent the simplest, most robust interpretation of the X-ray spectra of bright ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs); this has been taken as evidence for the presence of intermediate-mass black holes (BHs) (M ~ 10^3 Msun) in those sources. Here, we assess this claim by comparing the cool disc-blackbody model with a range of other models. For example, we show that the same ULX spectra can be fitted equally well by subtracting a disc-blackbody component from a dominant power-law component, thus turning a soft excess into a soft deficit. Then, we propose a more complex physical model, based on a power-law component slightly modified at various energies by smeared emission and absorption lines from highly-ionized, fast-moving gas. We use the XMM-Newton/EPIC spectra of two ULXs in Holmberg II and NGC 4559 as examples. Our main conclusion is that the presence of a soft excess or a soft deficit depends on the energy range over which we choose to fit the ``true'' power-law continuum; those small deviations from the power-law spectrum are well modelled by disc-blackbody components (either in emission or absorption) simply because they are a versatile fitting tool for most kinds of smooth, broad bumps. Hence, we argue that those components should not be taken as evidence for accretion disc emission, nor used to infer BH masses. Finally, we speculate that bright ULXs could be in a spectral state similar to (or an extension of) the steep-power-law state of Galactic BH candidates, in which the disc is now completely comptonized and not directly detectable, and the power-law emission may be modified by the surrounding, fast-moving, ionized gas.
12 pages, accepted by MNRAS
References in corpus (2)
Cited by in corpus (24)
- X-ray observations of ultraluminous X-ray sources
- Low metallicity and ultra-luminous X-ray sources in the Cartwheel galaxy
- Pulsator-like spectra from Ultraluminous X-ray sources and the search for more ultraluminous pulsars
- Enhanced activity of massive black holes by stellar capture assisted by a self-gravitating accretion disc
- Optical emission from massive donors in ULX binary systems
- Testing the Paradigm that Ultraluminous X-ray Sources as a Class Represent Accreting Intermediate-Mass Black Holes
- Long-term X-ray spectral evolution of Ultraluminous X-ray sources: implications on the accretion flow geometry and the nature of the accretor
- Bridging the gap between stellar-mass black holes and ultraluminous X-ray sources
- Irradiation models for ULXs and fits to optical data
- Discovery of mHz X-ray Oscillations in a Transient Ultraluminous X-ray Source in M82
- New Hubble Space Telescope imaging of the counterparts to six ultraluminous X-ray sources
- Chandra monitoring observations of the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 5204 X-1
- Intermediate-mass black holes and ultraluminous X-ray sources in the Cartwheel ring galaxy
- Accretion Disk Spectra of the Brightest Ultra-luminous X-ray Source in M82
- Elemental Abundances of Nearby Galaxies through High Signal-to-Noise XMM-Newton Observations of ULXs
- A deficit of ultraluminous X-ray sources in luminous infrared galaxies
- Evolution of the spectral curvature in the ULX Holmberg II X-1
- The dependence of the estimated luminosities of ULX on spectral models
- Thermal instability in X-ray photoionized media in Active Galactic Nuclei: Influence on the gas structure and spectral features
- A ULX associated with a cloud collision in M99
- Multiwavelength study of the bright X-ray source population in the interacting galaxies NGC5774/NGC5775
- Ultraluminous X-ray Sources in Seven Edge-On Spiral Galaxies
- Detection of X-ray elongated emission from a ultraluminous X-ray source in the interacting pair of galaxies NGC 5953/5954
- Black hole mass estimates from soft X-ray spectra