Dynamical stability of collisionless stellar systems and barotropic stars: the nonlinear Antonov first law

Abstract

We complete previous investigations on the dynamical stability of barotropic stars and collisionless stellar systems. A barotropic star that minimizes the energy functional at fixed mass is a nonlinearly dynamically stable stationary solution of the Euler-Poisson system. Formally, this minimization problem is similar to a condition of ``canonical stability'' in thermodynamics. A stellar system that maximizes an H-function at fixed mass and energy is a nonlinearly dynamically stable stationary solution of the Vlasov-Poisson system. Formally, this maximization problem is similar to a condition of ``microcanonical stability'' in thermodynamics. Using a thermodynamical analogy, we provide a derivation and an interpretation of the nonlinear Antonov first law in terms of ``ensembles inequivalence'': a spherical stellar system with f=f(epsilon) and f'(epsilon)<0 is nonlinearly dynamically stable with respect to the Vlasov-Poisson system if the corresponding barotropic star with the same equilibrium density distribution is nonlinearly dynamically stable with respect to the Euler-Poisson system. This is similar to the fact that ``canonical stability implies microcanonical stability'' in thermodynamics. The converse is wrong in case of ``ensembles inequivalence'' which is generic for systems with long-range interactions like gravity. We show that criteria of nonlinear dynamical stability can be obtained very simply from purely graphical constructions by using the method of series of equilibria and the turning point argument of Poincare, as in thermodynamics.

References in corpus (24)

• Thermodynamic Description of the Relaxation of Two-Dimensional Euler Turbulence Using Tsallis Statistics
• Generalized thermodynamics and Fokker-Planck equations. Applications to stellar dynamics, two-dimensional turbulence and Jupiter's great red spot
• Thermodynamics of self-gravitating systems
• Gravitational instability of finite isothermal spheres
• Classification of phase transitions and ensemble inequivalence, in systems with long range interactions
• Phase transitions in self-gravitating systems. Self-gravitating fermions and hard spheres models
• Dynamics and thermodynamics of a simple model similar to self-gravitating systems: the HMF model
• Thermodynamics and collapse of self-gravitating Brownian particles in D dimensions
• Non-linear stability of gaseous stars
• Gravitational instability of isothermal and polytropic spheres
• Stable steady states in stellar dynamics
• On the lifetime of metastable states in self-gravitating systems
• Fingerprints of nonextensive thermodynamics in a long-range Hamiltonian system
• Coarse-grained distributions and superstatistics
• Anomalous diffusion and collapse of self-gravitating Langevin particles in D dimensions
• Isotropic steady states in galactic dynamics revised
• Hamiltonian and Brownian systems with long-range interactions
• Gravitational instability of polytropic spheres and generalized thermodynamics
• A family of models of partially relaxed stellar systems II. Comparison with the products of collisionless collapse
• Statistical mechanics and phase diagrams of rotating self-gravitating fermions
• Gravothermal Catastrophe and Tsallis' Generalized Entropy of Self-Gravitating Systems III. quasi-equilibrium structure using normalized q-values
• A Note on the Statistical Mechanics of Violent Relaxation of Phase Space Elements of Different Densities
• Thermodynamical description of a family of partially relaxed stellar systems
• Classification of supersymmetric spacetimes in eleven dimensions

Cited by in corpus (24)

• Bose-Einstein Condensate general relativistic stars
• Cosmology with a stiff matter era
• Nonlinear mean field Fokker-Planck equations. Application to the chemotaxis of biological populations
• Kinetic theory of point vortices in two dimensions: analytical results and numerical simulations
• Lynden-Bell and Tsallis distributions for the HMF model
• Relativistic self-gravitating Bose-Einstein condensates and cold baryons with a stiff equation of state
• Role of $f(R,T,R_{\mu \nu }{T}^{\mu \nu })$ Model on the Stability of Cylindrical Stellar Model
• Logotropic distributions
• Relativistic stars with a linear equation of state: analogy with classical isothermal spheres and black holes
• White dwarf stars in D dimensions
• Dynamical stability criterion for inhomogeneous quasi-stationary states in long-range systems
• Dynamical stability of systems with long-range interactions: application of the Nyquist method to the HMF model
• Jeans mass-radius relation of self-gravitating Bose-Einstein condensates and typical parameters of the dark matter particle
• Statistical mechanics of self-gravitating systems in general relativity: I. The quantum Fermi gas
• Critical dynamics of self-gravitating Langevin particles and bacterial populations
• Inhomogeneous Tsallis distributions in the HMF model
• Phase transitions in self-gravitating systems and bacterial populations with a screened attractive potential
• Dynamical stability of infinite homogeneous self-gravitating systems: application of the Nyquist method
• Kinetic theory of collisionless relaxation for systems with long-range interactions
• Caloric curves of classical self-gravitating systems in general relativity
• Stable ground states for the relativistic gravitational Vlasov-Poisson system
• Caloric curves fitted by polytropic distributions in the HMF model
• Equilibrium and Dynamical Evolution of Self-Gravitating System Embedded in a Potential Well
• A new variational approach to the stability of gravitational systems