Significance in gamma-ray astronomy - the Li & Ma problem in Bayesian statistics

Abstract

The significance of having detected an astrophysical gamma ray source is usually calculated by means of a formula derived by Li & Ma in 1983. We solve the same problem in terms of Bayesian statistics, which provides a logically more satisfactory framework. We do not use any subjective elements in the present version of Bayesian statistics. We show that for large count numbers and a weak source the Li & Ma formula agrees with the Bayesian result. For other cases the two results differ, both due to the mathematically different treatment and the fact that only Bayesian inference can take into account prior knowldege.

arXiv comment12 pages, 3 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Bayesian Estimation of Hardness Ratios: Modeling and Computations
• Significance of an excess in a counting experiment: assessing the impact of systematic uncertainties and the case with Gaussian background
• Evidence of Intermediate-Scale Energy Spectrum Anisotropy of Cosmic Rays E$\ge$10${}^{19.2}$ eV with the Telescope Array Surface Detector
• Signal discovery, limits, and uncertainties with sparse On/Off measurements: an objective Bayesian analysis
• A generalized likelihood ratio test statistic for Cherenkov telescope data
• Dark matter search with the BDX-MINI experiment
• On Bayesian analysis of on-off measurements
• A Bayesian on-off analysis of cosmic ray data