Are stellar coronae optically thin in X-rays? - A systematic investigation of opacity effects

Abstract

The relevance of resonant scattering (absorption by photo-excitation and re-emission out of the line of sight) in the solar corona has always been discussed controversially. Ratios of emission lines from identical ions but different oscillator strengths are tracers for damping of resonance lines due to possible resonant scattering. We present an analysis of a large sample of 44 stellar spectra obtained with all gratings on board Chandra and XMM-Newton and systematically measure line ratios of FeXVII lines at 15.27A and 16.78A lines to the resonance line at 15.03A as well as the He-like f/r ratio of OVII and NeIX. The same ratios obtained from optically thin plasma atomic databases such as MEKAL, Chianti, and APEC are found to be discrepant, however, we find no convincing proof for resonance line scattering. Optical depths are basically identical for all kinds of stellar coronae and we conclude that identical optical depths are more probable when effects from resonant scattering are generally negligible. The 15.27/15.03A ratio shows a regular trend suggesting blending of the 15.27A line by a cooler Fe line, possibly FeXVI. The He-like f/r ratios for O and Ne show no indication for significant damping of the resonance lines. We mainly attribute deviations from the atomic databases to still uncertain emissivities which do not agree well with laboratory measurements and which come out with differing results when accounting for one or the other side effect.

13 pages, 13 figures, accepted for A&A

References in corpus (7)

• Collisional Plasma Models with APEC/APED: Emission Line Diagnostics of Hydrogen-like and Helium-like Ions
• CHIANTI - an Atomic Database for Emission Lines. Paper VI: Proton Rates and Other Improvements
• A Study of the Coronal Plasma in RS CVn binary systems
• Coronal density diagnostics with Helium-like triplets: CHANDRA--LETGS observations of Algol, Capella, Procyon, Eps Eri, Alpha Cen A&B, UX Ari, AD Leo, YY Gem, and HR1099
• Helium-like triplet density diagnostics: Applications to CHANDRA--LETGS X-ray observations of Capella and Procyon
• The X-ray spectrum of Fe XVII revisited with a multi-ion model
• Chandra LETGS Observation of the Active Binary Algol

Cited by in corpus (32)

• X-Ray Spectroscopy of Stars
• Coronal Evolution of the Sun in Time: High-Resolution X-Ray Spectroscopy of Solar Analogs with Different Ages
• Flares from small to large: X-ray spectroscopy of Proxima Centauri with XMM-Newton
• On the sizes of stellar X-ray coronae
• He-like ions as practical astrophysical plasma diagnostics: From stellar coronae to active galactic nuclei
• Relationship between X-ray and ultraviolet emission of flares from dMe stars observed by XMM-Newton
• Modeling the NeIX Triplet Spectral Region of Capella with the Chandra and XMM-Newton Gratings
• High-resolution X-ray spectroscopy of the evolving shock in the 2006 outburst of RS Ophiuchi
• The Transparency of Solar Coronal Active Regions
• High Resolution Photoexcitation Measurements Exacerbate the Long-Standing Fe XVII Oscillator Strength Problem
• Inferring coronal structure from X-ray lightcurves and Doppler shifts: a Chandra study of AB Doradus
• New Measurement Resolves Key Astrophysical Fe XVII Oscillator Strength Problem
• X-ray Spectroscopy of the Contact Binary VW Cephei
• Detection of X-ray Resonance Scattering in Active Stellar Coronae
• Coronal properties of the EQ Peg binary system
• X-ray optical depth diagnostics of T Tauri accretion shocks
• Coronal abundances from high-resolution X-ray data: The case of Algol
• On X-ray Optical Depth in the Coronae of Active Stars
• Some Like it Hot: The X-Ray Emission of The Giant Star YY Mensae
• Anomalous X-ray line ratios in the cTTS TW Hya
• The corona and upper transition region of epsilon Eridani
• Flare X-ray observations of AB Dor: evidence for Stellar Coronal Opacity
• A New Calculation of Ne IX Line Diagnostics
• High-resolution Laboratory Measurements of K-shell X-ray Line Polarization and Excitation Cross Sections in Heliumlike S XV Ions
• X-raying the AU Microscopii debris disk
• Line intensity enhancements in stellar coronal X-ray spectra due to opacity effects
• An XMM-Newton Study of the Coronae of ${\sigma }^2$ Coronae Borealis
• Soft X-ray emissions of highly charged Si VII--Si XII in cool star--Procyon
• An X-ray flare from 47 Cas
• Soft X-ray emissions of Si IX in Procyon
• Advances of plasma diagnostics with high-resolution spectroscopy of stellar coronae
• A benchmark of the He-like triplet for ions with $6\le Z\le 14$ in Maxwellian and non-Maxwellian plasmas