Force Free Waves and Black Hole Magnetospheric Causality
arXiv:astro-ph/0210103 · doi:10.1086/345422
Abstract
The force free approximation is often useful when describing tenuous plasmas in strong cosmic magnetic fields. Time evolution of any such system is governed by the information that can be transported along the characteristics of the plasma modes allowed by the force free constraint. This brief article elucidates, for the first time, the nature of the information that can be transported along the characteristics for each of the two plasma modes, the Alfven and fast modes. It is reassuring that these modes behave as one would expect if the perfect magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) modes in a magnetically dominated plasma were evaluated in the limit of zero plasma inertia (i.e., only allowed to propagate information consistent with the force free constraint). There are no properties of these waves that do not exist within the MHD theory, when this additional constraint on the current is imposed. The results of the characteristic analysis elucidates the nature of the causality violation in force free black hole magnetospheres. The most significant result from the standpoint of global causality is that charge and current perturbations can not be transported along the fast mode short wavelength characteristics in the force free limit.
Accepted by ApJ. This rectifies gross errors in a simple short wavelength force free calculation posted on astro-ph that was intended to discredit the MHD analysis of black hole GHM
References in corpus (3)
Cited by in corpus (15)
- A Measurement of the Electromagnetic Luminosity of a Kerr Black Hole
- Simulations of Axisymmetric Magnetospheres of Neutron Stars
- The pulsar force-free magnetosphere linked to its striped wind: time-dependent pseudo-spectral simulations
- Force-Free Magnetosphere of an Accretion Disk -- Black Hole System. II. Kerr Geometry
- Introducing PHAEDRA: a new spectral code for simulations of relativistic magnetospheres
- Ohm's Law in the Fast Lane: General Relativistic Charge Dynamics
- Computational General Relativistic Force-Free Electrodynamics: II. Characterization of Numerical Diffusivity
- Electromagnetic extraction of energy from Kerr black holes
- Non-thermal high-energy emissions from black holes by a relativistic capillary effect
- Isothermal Plasma Waves in Gravitomagnetic Planar Analogue
- Force-free wave interaction in magnetar magnetospheres: Computational modeling in axisymmetry
- Computational General Relativistic Force-Free Electrodynamics: I. Multi-Coordinate Implementation and Testing
- On time evolution and causality of force-free black hole magnetospheres
- The origins of Causality Violations in Force Free Simulations of Black Hole Magnetospheres
- Fast Wave Polarization, Charge Horizons and the Time Evolution of Force-Free Magnetospheres