paper

On the metallicity of the Milky Way thin disc and photometric abundance scales

arXiv:astro-ph/0206500 · doi:10.1046/j.1365-8711.2002.05935.x

Abstract

The mean metallicity of the Milky Way thin disc in the solar neighbourhood is still a matter of debate, and has recently been subject to upward revision (Haywood, 2001). Our star sample was drawn from a set of solar neighbourhood dwarfs with photometric metallicities. In a recent study, Reid (2002) suggests that our metallicity calibration, based on Geneva photometry, is biased. We show here that the effect detected by Reid is not a consequence of our adopted metallicity scale, and we confirm that our findings are robust. On the contrary, the application to Stromgren photometry of the Schuster & Nissen metallicity scale is problematic. Systematic discrepancies of about 0.1 to 0.3 dex affect the photometric metallicity determination of metal rich stars, on the colour interval 0.22< b-y <0.59, i.e including F and G stars. For F stars, it is shown that this is a consequence of a mismatch between the standard sequence m_1(b-y) of the Hyades used by Schuster & Nissen to calibrate their metallicity scale, and the system of Olsen (1993, 1994ab). It means that although Schuster & Nissen calibration and Olsen photometry are intrinsically correct, there are mutually incompatible for metal rich, F-type stars. For G stars, the discrepancy is most probably the continuation of the same problem, albeit worthen by the lack of spectroscopic calibrating stars. A corrected calibration is proposed which renders the calibration of Schuster & Nissen applicable to the catalogues of Olsen. We also give a simpler calibration referenced to the Hyades sequence, valid over the same color and metallicity ranges.

11 pages, 11 figures, accepted in MNRAS

References in corpus (4)

Cited by in corpus (24)