Statistical Re-examination of Reported Emission Lines in the X-ray Afterglow of GRB 011211

Abstract

(abridged) A 0.2-12 keV spectrum obtained with the XMM EPIC/pn instrument of GRB 011211 was found by Reeves et al. (2002) to contain emission lines which were interpreted to be from Mg XI, Si XIV, S XVI, Ar XVIII, and Ca XX, at a lower redshift (z_{obs}=1.88) than the host galaxy (z_{host}=2.14). We examine the spectrum independently, and find that the claimed lines would not be discovered in a blind search. Specifically, Monte Carlo simulations show that they would be observed in 10% of featureless spectra with the same signal-to-noise. Imposing a model in which the two brightest lines would be Si XIV and S XVI K-alpha emission possibly velocity shifted to between z=1.88--2.40, such features would be found in between ~1.2-2.6% of observed featureless spectra. We find the detection significances to be insufficient to justify the claim of detection and the model put forth to explain them. K-alpha line complexes are also found at z=1.2 and z=2.75 of significance equal to or greater than that at z=1.88. If one adopts the z=1.88 complex as significant, one must also adopt the other two complexes to be significant. The interpretation of these data in the context of the model proposed by Reeves et al. is therefore degenerate, and cannot be resolved by these data alone.

23 pages, 4 figures. MNRAS, accepted. Expanded discussion

References in corpus (4)

• Statistics: Handle with Care, Detecting Multiple Model Components with the Likelihood Ratio Test
• The Signature of Supernova Ejecta Measured in the X-ray Afterglow of Gamma-Ray Burst 011211
• Soft X-ray emission lines in the early afterglow of gamma-ray bursts
• Observations of the X-ray Afterglows of GRB011211 and GRB001025 by XMM-Newton

Cited by in corpus (22)

• The Physics of Gamma-Ray Bursts
• The Supernova -- Gamma-Ray Burst Connection
• Supernova Hosts for Gamma-Ray Burst Jets: Dynamical Constraints
• Probing the environment in Gamma-ray bursts: the case of an X-ray precursor, afterglow late onset and wind vs constant density profile in GRB011121 and GRB011211
• Effects of color superconductivity on the structure and formation of compact stars
• Neutron Star Radius Measurement with the Quiescent Low-Mass X-ray Binary U24 in NGC 6397
• Low-resolution VLT spectroscopy of GRBs 991216, 011211 and 021211
• The X-ray Afterglows of GRB 020813 and GRB 021004 with Chandra HETGS: Possible Evidence for a Supernova Prior to GRB 020813
• Delayed soft X-ray emission lines in the afterglow of GRB 030227
• The Polar Regions of Cassiopeia A: The Aftermath of a Gamma Ray Burst?
• On the Early Time X-ray Spectra of Swift Afterglows I: Evidence for Anomalous Soft X-ray Emission
• Line Searches in Swift X-ray Spectra
• Explosive Nucleosynthesis Associated with Formation of Jet-induced GRBs in Massive Stars
• Nucleosynthesis inside Gamma-Ray Burst Accretion Disks
• A Search for Discrete X-ray Spectral Features in a Sample of Bright Gamma-ray Burst Afterglows
• The prompt X-ray emission of GRB011211: possible evidence of a transient absorption feature
• Gamma-ray bursts as X-ray depth-gauges of the Universe
• High Resolution Gratings Spectroscopy of GRBs 030382 and 041006 with Chandra LETGS
• Optical Limits on Precursor Emission from Gamma-Ray Bursts with Known Redshift
• A search for lines in the bright X-ray afterglow of GRB120711A
• Reconsidering the origin of the X-ray emission lines in GRB 011211
• Matched-filtering Line Search Methods Applied to Suzaku Data