Does a Second-Class Primary Constraint Generate a Gauge Transformation? Electromagnetisms and Gravities, Massless and Massive
arXiv:2609.31809 · doi:10.1016/j.aop.2024.169621
Abstract
In constrained Hamiltonian dynamics there are two views regarding how first-class constraints generate gauge transformations: individually or only in a certain combination, the Rosenfeld-Anderson-Bergmann-Castellani gauge generator. This gauge generator preserves Hamilton's equations and changes the canonical action at most by a boundary term; Hamiltonian's equations are the Euler-Lagrange equations for the canonical action. Hence the canonical formalism is equivalent to the Lagrangian formalism, and indeed subsumed within it (in important examples) with many canonical momenta serving as auxiliary fields. generates transformations basically equivalent to the usual 4-dimensional Lagrangian expressions, such as a 4-gradient in electromagnetism or a space-time coordinate transformation (on-shell) in General Relativity. It has been shown recently that separate first-class constraints lead to inequivalent observables between Proca non-gauge and Stueckelberg gauge massive electromagnetism. There is, however, widespread agreement that second-class constraints do not generate gauge transformations. Here it is shown that in such a sense as the first-class primary constraint in Maxwell's theory generates a gauge transformation, the second-class primary constraint in Proca's massive electromagnetism also generates a gauge transformation. Likewise the second-class primary constraints in various massive spin relatives of General Relativity generate as much of a gauge transformation as do the corresponding first-class primary constraints in GR. Hence the view that first-class constraints typically generate gauge transformations _individually_ faces a puzzle not faced by the gauge generator view.
References in corpus (22)
- Resummation of Massive Gravity
- Effective Field Theory for Massive Gravitons and Gravity in Theory Space
- Photon and Graviton Mass Limits
- The Stueckelberg Field
- Finite-Range Gravity and Its Role in Gravitational Waves, Black Holes and Cosmology
- Change in Hamiltonian General Relativity from the Lack of a Time-like Killing Vector Field
- A First Class Constraint Generates Not a Gauge Transformation, But a Bad Physical Change: The Case of Electromagnetism
- Observables in classical canonical gravity: folklore demystified
- Universally Coupled Massive Gravity
- Artificial vs Substantial Gauge Symmetries: a Criterion and an Application to the Electroweak Model
- Permanent Underdetermination from Approximate Empirical Equivalence in Field Theory: Massless and Massive Scalar Gravity, Neutrino, Electromagnetic, Yang-Mills and Gravitational Theories
- Gauge Transformations in Einstein-Yang-Mills Theories
- The Nontriviality of Trivial General Covariance: How Electrons Restrict 'Time' Coordinates, Spinors (Almost) Fit into Tensor Calculus, and 7/16 of a Tetrad Is Surplus Structure
- Léon Rosenfeld's general theory of constrained Hamiltonian dynamics
- Gravitational-wave research as an emerging field in the Max Planck Society. The long roots of GEO600 and of the Albert Einstein Institute
- Dimensional reduction and gauge group reduction in Bianchi-Type cosmology
- Universally Coupled Massive Gravity, III: dRGT-Maheshwari Pure Spin-, Ogievetsky-Polubarinov and Arbitrary Mass Terms
- Massive Nordström Scalar (Density) Gravities from Universal Coupling
- Equivalent Theories and Changing Hamiltonian Observables in General Relativity
- Quantum Aspects of Massive Gravity II: Non-Pauli-Fierz Theory
- Universally Coupled Massive Gravity, II: Densitized Tetrad and Cotetrad Theories
- Constrained Dynamics of Universally Coupled Massive Spin 2-spin 0 Gravities