paper

Heterogeneous Policy Effects in Comparative Case Studies with Treated-Unit Microdata

arXiv:2609.28678

Abstract

This article develops an identification framework for heterogeneous policy effects when individual-level data are available only in the treated jurisdiction. The framework combines outcome changes from repeated cross-sections within that jurisdiction with a population-average effect identified from aggregate panel data. Under conditional relative parallel trends and overlap, this information identifies subgroup effects standardized to the treated jurisdiction's overall post-treatment covariate distribution, but generally not effects averaged over each subgroup's own distribution. I establish how these subgroup-average effects can nevertheless be recovered using covariate-specific aggregate effects or additional pretreatment observations under assumptions about the evolution of untreated trends. Simulations and an application to the Massachusetts health reform illustrate the framework.