From Reasoning Strings to Partial Orders: Verifier-Certified Rule Transport through Quotient Policy Optimization

Abstract

Many computations admit several valid execution orders because independent subgoals or disjoint state updates can commute. Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards usually treats each successful trace as a separate token sequence, so serialization choices can be mistaken for logical dependencies. We introduce Verifier-Certified Rule Transport (VCRT), which replays adjacent operation pairs with native verifiers. Pairs whose two orders are accepted and reach the same canonical state provide commutation certificates; rejected or state-changing reversals provide anti-diamonds. VCRT uses anti-diamonds to preserve genuine prerequisites and assigns policy credit to the total probability mass of each certified orbit. It also constrains post-swap consistency, source retention, and policy drift. We evaluate leave-one-environment-out transfer across ProofWriter, CLRS, and Lean through a shared anonymized relation-graph interface. All training and checkpoint decisions are frozen before held-out evaluation, which uses one greedy trajectory per item without search or verifier feedback. VCRT obtains a 77.60% macro pass rate versus 64.53% for the strongest matched baseline, a paired gain of 13.06 points (95% bootstrap CI [12.58, 13.54]). Lean accounts for most of this gain at 33.49 points, while ProofWriter and CLRS improve by 2.85 points on average. Mechanism tests consistently favor anti-diamond supervision, whereas No-Orbit is statistically indistinguishable from full VCRT. The evidence does not establish a general benefit from exact orbit aggregation.

9 pages, 2 figures, 4 tables