paper

The winner's curse in hardware VQE: drift-differenced remeasurement of finite-shot selection bias

arXiv:2609.27704 · doi:10.1088/2058-9565/aeb4e8

Abstract

Finite-shot optimization can make noisy variational quantum eigensolver energies look artificially accurate. We studied six hardware-tractable molecular active spaces on two IBM Heron r3 processors. Seven optimizer-selected values fell below the exact active-space eigenvalue by up to 17.36 mHa. The cell-balanced fraction of the source-observed best-final advantage not retained on later fixed-parameter measurement was 0.989 (approximate 95% session-level interval [0.906, 1.072]); alternative aggregations span 0.892-0.989. Thus little of the selected advantage remained on average. Measurements occurred 5.6-38.4 days later, so parameter-dependent drift remains a competing explanation. Best-observed hardware VQE values require prompt independent confirmation before supporting accuracy claims.

arXiv commentComments: 35 pages including Supplementary Information; revised analysis and presentation, added offline software-compatibility controls and released analysis code