Low-dimensional Galerkin projection models for predicting turbulent secondary mean flow in a square duct

Abstract

The presence of sidewalls in turbulent duct flows leads to the emergence of secondary flow structures in the form of counter-rotating streamwise vortices near the corners (Prandtl's secondary flow of the second kind). This work develops reduced-order Galerkin projection models that can predict the emergence and structure of these turbulent mean secondary flows in a square duct geometry, without requiring any prior knowledge of the turbulent statistics. The models are obtained by projecting the Navier--Stokes equations onto eigenmodes of the linearised system, with the resulting systems of ordinary differential equations simulated with the addition of zero-mean forcing. We show that most models obtained using leading streamwise-constant eigenmodes predict the correct shape and direction of the secondary mean, with the minimal such model requiring only two modes. In these models, the secondary mean contribution arises due to the nonzero average coefficient of an eigenmode that possesses all of the symmetry properties expected of a secondary mean. The models are sufficiently simple such that the relationship between this mean coefficient and the joint second moment of other mode coefficients can be computed analytically. We confirm that running streamwise-constant direct numerical simulations (DNS) with the same forcing structure as used in the reduced-order models produces similar secondary-flow structures. We additionally demonstrate that our models produce qualitatively similar Reynolds stress distributions to fully resolved direct numerical simulations, with improved agreement as model dimension increases.