Are Near Resonant Multiple-planet Systems from Kepler Young?

Abstract

Recent studies have claimed that Kepler multi-planet systems hosting near-resonant planet pairs---particularly those near second-order mean-motion resonances (MMRs)---exhibit smaller stellar velocity dispersions than the general population of Kepler planet hosts. Interpreting velocity dispersion as an age indicator, these works concluded that near-resonant systems are systematically younger. We revisit this claim, but we explicitly account for contamination by thick disk stars, which are kinematically hotter and follow a different age-velocity dispersion relation (AVR) than thin disk stars. Using the kinematic criterion to separate thin and thick disk stars, we show that systems classified as having plausible second-order resonant pairs are preferentially hosted by brighter, closer stars and are therefore less contaminated by thick disk stars than the overall sample. After applying a cut to remove probable thick disk contaminants ($TD/D<0.1$), the vertical velocity dispersion of near-resonant systems becomes statistically indistinguishable from that of the overall Kepler multi-planet sample. We conclude that the apparent kinematic youth of near-resonant systems in Kepler may not be due to a genuine age difference, but rather arises from observational selection effects linked to host star properties and planet detectability. We also comment on the kinematic ages of ultra-short-period planets (USPs).

7 pages, 5 figures, accepted. For a related issue, see our companion paper (Q. Hu et al.) appearing on the same day on arXiv